Showing posts with label profitability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label profitability. Show all posts

Friday, September 23, 2011

Jobs Cannot Be Simply Created

One thing that is a near constant in all discussions regarding the current economic situation is that they entirely neglect consideration of ultimate causes and instead focus on particular manifestations of the underlying problem. The result, of course, is always failure.

Take recent discussions about jobs. It has not, at any point, been off of people's minds the past couple years or so, and president Obama just released a new jobs plan. The common belief is that a few policy decisions - a tweak here, a tweak there - can "create" more jobs. And then the economy will get better. The end.

Everyone ignores the relationships and tensions between employment levels, wages, productivity, and profitability. For example, the fact that under capitalism there is a necessary ("natural") level of unemployment, without which the system would cease to function. Or the fact that new jobs will ultimately be superfluous if the system lacks the general conditions necessary to sustain the profitability of capitalist enterprises: conditions that relate more to the current organization and scale of production than to simple considerations of supply and demand.

One popular idea is that the government should make it less expensive for employers to hire new people (e.g. by reducing the payroll tax). This is yet another move in the several-decades-long trend toward shifting the costs of labor more onto the laborers themselves. If the government makes it less expensive for employers to hire people, what they are doing, in essence, is further subsidizing the cost of labor. Instead of employers bearing all the burden of the costs of the labor from which they derive their profits, the responsibility is pooled with other employers and all of the laborers themselves. And since some major corporations and wealthy individuals get away with paying practically no taxes at all, that is quite a large shift in burden.

Capitalist enterprises have become far less profitable over the past few decades. Capitalists respond to this situation, not by addressing the structural problems that are ultimately responsible, but by trying to reduce the costs of labor bit by bit in order to keep turning out a profit. Of course this is unsustainable in the long run (for one thing it reduces demand), but capitalists do not think about the long run (particularly when the long run does not look good for them either way). They think about how much money they can milk out of the system here and now, even as they watch it collapse.

So, we focus on making it "easier" for capitalists to hire. And easier for capitalists to hire also means easier for capitalists to skim off the last bit of profits before everything falls apart.

If you want to talk about jobs and capitalism, consider this: capitalism was only able to develop as a result of unemployment. If there were no mass of landless, unemployed peasants, capitalism as we know it would not exist. Clearly, seeing everyone employed is not a capitalist's top priority.

The best way to keep everyone employed is to get rid of capitalism.

Saturday, May 21, 2011

The Rise of China

I am not the only person who argues that U.S. hegemony has been steadily eroding for the past few decades. The question I posed at the end of my last post (what comes next?) is one that is frequently considered and debated by others. This usually occurs in the context of discussions about China. For China is seen as the most likely heir to the U.S. in its role as world superpower (whether this is viewed as a potential threat or an inevitability).

I do not believe that China, or even some East Asian regional block, will be the next hegemonic power. There are two primary reasons for my doubt:

1. China's economic development is based solely on strategic participation in the world market and manufacturing.

Strategic participation: Decades ago, when China was still considered a Third World country, it allied with the Soviet sphere of hegemony rather than that of the U.S. However, China also managed to maintain some distance and independence from the Soviet Union, so that it was never truly a member of the Soviet empire. As a result, China could protect itself against the types of neocolonial exploitation that ravaged other Third World nations (particularly those in the "free world.") When the growth of the world economy came to a screetching halt, China was perfectly poised to take advantage of the situation. Its ability to employ protectionist policies to limit imports and keep the exchange value of its currency low, among other things, has allowed China to develop its manufacturing sector and dominate foreign markets, despite a global crisis of overproduction. However, China succeeds in this regard only to the extent that everyone else fails. In the end, because China is dependent on foreign demand for its products and foreign investment, decrease in global demand and foreign debt crises threaten to undermine the stability of China's economic development.

Manufacturing: The profitability of Chinese manufacturing results from the cheap production costs enabled by protectionist policies and the persistent level of global demand for manufactured products (purposefully cultivated in an effort to ignite demand-driven economic growth). However, once again, this is short-term. In the long run, manufacturing, as it is currently organized socially, politically, logistically, and geographically, will never be able to overcome the crisis of overproduction that has been suffocating its ability to generate adequate rates of profit for decades. Thus, Chinese manufacturing will only be profitable for so long. It cannot overcome the crisis of overproduction.

2. Before the next world order emerges, substantial transformations of current political-economic structures will have to occur. This includes the geopolitical framework of the system of nation-states.  As the social/spatial/mechanical organization of production undergoes radical changes, so too will human geography and institutions such as states and transnational organizations (e.g. the UN).  The map may soon look drastically different.  Indeed, the chaos of multipolarity, which I discussed in my previous post, seems to prefigure such a change.  Thus, it does not make sense to look for the next superpower among the current collection of nation-states.  The answer to the the "What will come next?" question is something that does not yet exist.

China might be having a bit of a hey-day (though nothing that compares to its past splendor), but more in the form of a vulture feasting on a rotting carcass.

Saturday, March 5, 2011

Accumulation of Wealth

I have already discussed some of the inherent contradictions of the capitalist system, but I think it is important to identify some more general characteristics of the accumulation of wealth, based on historical patterns, that may shed some light on those that pertain specifically to capitalism (the items in my list below link to previous posts so that a comparison may be made).

**By accumulation of wealth, I mean accumulation far beyond what one can produce by oneself or among a freely associating group of people, given whatever technology is available at the time.

1.  It occurs at the expense of others.
2.  It is generally dependent on some form of state support.
3.  It is dependent on limitations to competition.
4.  It is always unsustainable in the long run.
     -The greater the economic expansion, the more strain is put on the system, and thus the bigger and faster the subsequent collapse
5.  Continuing to invest in a profitable enterprise ultimately reduces its profitability.
6.  Expansion occurs primarily via:
     -Strategic monopolies
     -The debt of other people
7.  Contrary to neoliberal ideology:
     -Success derives from a mixture of relative initial weakness and historical accident
     -The most successful enterprises lose their adaptability in the process of attaining their success and ultimately fail
     -Unfettered competition generally leads to decreased profitability for everyone