I have already described how exploitation of the so-called “Third World” has proceeded over the past few centuries according to a succession of variants (though the basic theme remains the same), and I have also explained how that exploitation has been and continues to be vital for capitalist/industrial profitability. In another post, I delineated to some extent the rigidity of the global hierarchy of wealth.
Specifically, I think it is important to emphasize that the only time during which the lower rungs make some sort of progress is when the top of the pyramid (the industrial north) experiences any kind of set-back. In a very simplistic and abstract way (which very much belies the complexity of the actual mechanisms of change), this is due to the fact that wealth is finite (based, of course, on a given level of technology) and essentially zero-sum (just like, for all you physics fans, the amount of energy in a closed system never increases or decreases, but merely changes form).
Now, on a slight tangent, I have heard some official reports from institutions like the World Bank that extreme poverty has recently been reduced around the world. Get out the champagne, right? Unfortunately, I would not put too much stock in this claim. For one thing, official statistics regarding global poverty produced by multilateral organizations like the World Bank tend to be extremely misleading and, quite frankly, useless. Not only do these organizations have agendas (as instruments of the industrial north), but statistics, in general, tend to be ineffective for understanding poverty. A true Marxist looks to structural realities and daily experiences. Take a look at any local newspaper in a Third World nation, and you will see no evidence of improvement in the conditions faced by ordinary people. (Where there are gains, these tend to concentrated at the top of the internal hierarchy, in typical capitalist inquality-increasing fashion.)
Regarding the structural realities, it is clear that the basic pecking order, the global relations of domination, has not changed. At all. And since gains in the underdeveloped world come at the expense of the industrial north, they are almost always limited and temporary.
Often, gains are temporary because the industrial north tries to regain their position in much the same way that, when two people are struggling to stay afloat in a pool, one tries to stay above water by holding the other down. This happened at the end of the 1970s. Global economic stagnation had set in by the late 1960s (caused by a crisis of overproduction and merely exacerbated by the energy crisis). As growth slowed in the industrial north, the Third World made some impressive gains. This was especially facilitated by the initial attempt of capital to find areas of investment and possibilities for cheaper production in other parts of the world.
But then the 80s, and with it the Reagan-Thatcher brand of neoliberalism, rolled in and flattened the developing world. The policies (“austerity measures,” if you will) of the industrial powers undermined all the prior investments and resulted in devastating financial crises which destroyed any economic progress made in the Third World in the previous decade.
In the intervening years we had some bubbles that did not resolve any of the underlying problems of overproduction, but made us feel pretty good about ourselves, nonetheless. Shockingly, the bubbles burst and we once again found ourselves on bumpy terrain. And once again, whose head are we going to hold under water so that we might have another gasp of air? Who are we going to screw over in an attempt to save ourselves? It seems that the EU is busy devising new ways to drain the world of its wealth and resources.
Check It. Sorry, Africans!
Showing posts with label economic cycles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economic cycles. Show all posts
Wednesday, March 21, 2012
Sunday, January 22, 2012
Democracy and Capitalism
The title of this post is also the title of a recent On Point episode. It begins by questioning: "Is Democracy up to the challenges of this century? Is Capitalism? We’ll look at two great pillars, and the questions now around them."
As the episode began, I was excited to hear a mainstream news outlet actually addressing these questions. However, as things progressed, particularly when Gideon Rose began to speak, it was clear that no one was willing to really question the taken-for-granted ideas about our political economic system. It became the same old line about "our system is really great, or at least the best we can hope for, but we just need to make some tweaks to make it work better." Yawn.
Gideon Rose asserted that, if we could just somehow get things to work the way the did in the Good Old Days (1950s and 60s) then more wealth would be generated and it could be spread around to level inequality and alleviate poverty in the U.S. This line of reasoning very well demonstrates the myopia and Americentrism that pervades the thought of most economists. Things may have been going well in the U.S. (and the other industrialized powers) in the post-WW2 period, but that does not mean that capitalism was creating and spreading wealth on a global scale! In fact, the rest of the world (even if one excludes the communist world) was mired in poverty as a direct result of the global relationships that enabled expansion in the industrialized centers. Income inequality was much more polarized on a global scale. So yes, the 1950s-60s were great times... if you ignore the rest of the world.
In this vein, Rose and Kupchan both seem to think that globalization is a recent phenomenon. It may be more visibly now in the first world, as corporations have moved their manufacturing operations to other parts of the world in order to exploit cheap labor and resources. People in the U.S. and Western Europe are suddenly angry that "their" jobs are being sent elsewhere. But, capitalism has always been a global system. In the post-WW2 era and earlier, manufacturing in the U.S. and Western Europe depended on the cheap raw material inputs from other parts of the world, which were obtained under conditions of colonial/neo-colonial exploitation. The citizens of the first world, furthermore, depended for their high standard of living on the unequal global exchange relationships that allowed them to purchase, with money representing a small fraction of their own labor hours, commodities whose actual production required a far greater number of someone else's labor hours.
Furthermore, Rose and Kupchan never seem to consider why the Great Capitalism of the post-WW2 era didn't last for more than a couple decades. Was it just that people got bored and wanted to try something new, as if an economy were a pair of shoes? If this form of capitalism was so great, why was it not preserved? In truth, the conditions of the post-WW2 era could not be sustained because of the inherent contradictions of capitalism, that transformed a period of great economic expansion, through the the workings of its fundamental logic, into a period of great economic stagnation. Specifically, the revolutions in production (assembly line technology, mechanization, transnational organization), which are responsible for the economic boom enjoyed by a fraction of the world's population, also laid the groundwork for its own demise. Production was proceeding at a scale that far outstripped actual human needs, and profitability plummeted. Everyone became Keynesians and tried to manufacture demand to keep up with the unnecessarily ballooning supply. Result: increased consumerism, accelerated cycles of production (i.e. things become obsolete much more quickly so that people are constantly having to buy new stuff), private and public indebtedness, bombardment by advertisements and corporate sponsorships... As it turned out, trying to artificially manufacture demand never solved the problem of overproduction; profitability was never restored and now everyone is saddled with massive debts.
Precisely for this reason I would say, contrary to Rose and Kupchan, that capitalism does not come in different forms. It comes in one form (whose basis is wage labor and generalized commodity production), with varying levels of state involvement and approaches to social welfare depending on ever-fluctuating circumstances determined by capitalism's underlying and unchanging logic. The state is an instrument of the capitalist class, and so it is used strategically to respond to changing environments and maintain the general conditions that are necessary for capitalism to function.
Rose says that, among the members of the Occupy Wall Street movement, it is the smart ones who want to return to the capitalism of the 1950s-60s. I can only find that statement arrogant and offensive. Wouldn't the smart ones be those who are able to think outside the bounds of dominant ideology?
As the episode began, I was excited to hear a mainstream news outlet actually addressing these questions. However, as things progressed, particularly when Gideon Rose began to speak, it was clear that no one was willing to really question the taken-for-granted ideas about our political economic system. It became the same old line about "our system is really great, or at least the best we can hope for, but we just need to make some tweaks to make it work better." Yawn.
Gideon Rose asserted that, if we could just somehow get things to work the way the did in the Good Old Days (1950s and 60s) then more wealth would be generated and it could be spread around to level inequality and alleviate poverty in the U.S. This line of reasoning very well demonstrates the myopia and Americentrism that pervades the thought of most economists. Things may have been going well in the U.S. (and the other industrialized powers) in the post-WW2 period, but that does not mean that capitalism was creating and spreading wealth on a global scale! In fact, the rest of the world (even if one excludes the communist world) was mired in poverty as a direct result of the global relationships that enabled expansion in the industrialized centers. Income inequality was much more polarized on a global scale. So yes, the 1950s-60s were great times... if you ignore the rest of the world.
In this vein, Rose and Kupchan both seem to think that globalization is a recent phenomenon. It may be more visibly now in the first world, as corporations have moved their manufacturing operations to other parts of the world in order to exploit cheap labor and resources. People in the U.S. and Western Europe are suddenly angry that "their" jobs are being sent elsewhere. But, capitalism has always been a global system. In the post-WW2 era and earlier, manufacturing in the U.S. and Western Europe depended on the cheap raw material inputs from other parts of the world, which were obtained under conditions of colonial/neo-colonial exploitation. The citizens of the first world, furthermore, depended for their high standard of living on the unequal global exchange relationships that allowed them to purchase, with money representing a small fraction of their own labor hours, commodities whose actual production required a far greater number of someone else's labor hours.
Furthermore, Rose and Kupchan never seem to consider why the Great Capitalism of the post-WW2 era didn't last for more than a couple decades. Was it just that people got bored and wanted to try something new, as if an economy were a pair of shoes? If this form of capitalism was so great, why was it not preserved? In truth, the conditions of the post-WW2 era could not be sustained because of the inherent contradictions of capitalism, that transformed a period of great economic expansion, through the the workings of its fundamental logic, into a period of great economic stagnation. Specifically, the revolutions in production (assembly line technology, mechanization, transnational organization), which are responsible for the economic boom enjoyed by a fraction of the world's population, also laid the groundwork for its own demise. Production was proceeding at a scale that far outstripped actual human needs, and profitability plummeted. Everyone became Keynesians and tried to manufacture demand to keep up with the unnecessarily ballooning supply. Result: increased consumerism, accelerated cycles of production (i.e. things become obsolete much more quickly so that people are constantly having to buy new stuff), private and public indebtedness, bombardment by advertisements and corporate sponsorships... As it turned out, trying to artificially manufacture demand never solved the problem of overproduction; profitability was never restored and now everyone is saddled with massive debts.
Precisely for this reason I would say, contrary to Rose and Kupchan, that capitalism does not come in different forms. It comes in one form (whose basis is wage labor and generalized commodity production), with varying levels of state involvement and approaches to social welfare depending on ever-fluctuating circumstances determined by capitalism's underlying and unchanging logic. The state is an instrument of the capitalist class, and so it is used strategically to respond to changing environments and maintain the general conditions that are necessary for capitalism to function.
Rose says that, among the members of the Occupy Wall Street movement, it is the smart ones who want to return to the capitalism of the 1950s-60s. I can only find that statement arrogant and offensive. Wouldn't the smart ones be those who are able to think outside the bounds of dominant ideology?
Labels:
capitalism,
democracy,
economic cycles,
occupy,
overproduction
Sunday, July 31, 2011
Inside Job
I managed to not see Inside Job (the 2010 documentary) until a couple nights ago. Well, I guess I'm only a year behind, and for me that's pretty good. Naturally, I want to write about my reaction to the film.
The film did a fairly good job at demonstrating the lack of separation between private and public, business and government. Although this is in keeping with Marx's contention that the state is merely a tool of the capitalist class and not an independent entity, Inside Job suggested that this state of affairs is a sort of perversion rather than the norm. In fact, just restricting one's attention to the United States, there has never been a time when business interests were independent from the state. The country was founded by elite land owners, and has been run by people with business connections ever since. That is the inherent nature of a state, not a perversion of it.
The film also showed how these business interests cut across the boundaries of individual presidencies. It does not matter who is in office, Republican or Democrat, liberal or conservative. That is more of a symbolic matter. Behind the illusion of different personalities and disparate ideologies, there lies the same corporate elite making all of the decisions.
The primary argument of the documentary is that the root cause of the financial crisis can be traced back to the period of deregulation of the financial sector inaugurated by Reagan.
First, I think it is important to note that deregulation began under Carter's presidency, not Reagan. Volcker, who they noted was a VP for Chase Manhattan bank (but failed to mention was the chairman of the Federal Reserve from 1979 into the 80s, and thus responsible for many of policies they decried), was appointed by Carter. Once again, individual presidencies do not matter. It was the VP of a major bank who was really calling the shots.
Second, it is also necessary to remember that financial deregulation was a response to global economic stagnation which set in at the end of the 1960s. It's not like the economy was doing great before hand. Yes, Keynesian strategies prevented any major recessions from occurring, but they did not resolve underlying stagnation (thus, "stagflation") or contribute to any growth. Therefore, financial deregulation cannot be held as a root cause; it itself is a symptom of a broader crisis of overproduction.
This is all in keeping with a general pattern regarding periods of economic stagnation. Such periods are always characterized by a shift in focus from productive activities (which no longer yield good returns) to high finance. And the shift toward financialization is always the nail in the coffin, the thing that leads to ultimate collapse before global economic and political structures are eventually reorganized. It is representative of the attempts of the wealthy elite to try to get as much out of the system as they can before it finally implodes.
Several of the interviewees in Inside Job made a good point: the wealth that was created from the 1980s onward was imaginary: it was not rooted in material or creative processes; it was spun out of thin air (out of debt, actually). This is in keeping with my point in the last paragraph (that dependence on high finance is a last-ditch effort that is chosen when material/creative processes are declining in profitability), but it also illustrates a more general Marxist principle. Marx insisted that economic processes could not be understood apart from material productive relationships. When one forgets that profits, investment, monetary transactions, etc. only occur in relation to production - particularly the manufacturing sector - then one imbues statistics and economic indicators with a power they do not have. For, if material productive processes are faltering, it does not matter how much stock prices are rising or asset values increasing, or income growing. Because wealth can temporarily be spun out of thin air, but only temporarily.
The film did a fairly good job at demonstrating the lack of separation between private and public, business and government. Although this is in keeping with Marx's contention that the state is merely a tool of the capitalist class and not an independent entity, Inside Job suggested that this state of affairs is a sort of perversion rather than the norm. In fact, just restricting one's attention to the United States, there has never been a time when business interests were independent from the state. The country was founded by elite land owners, and has been run by people with business connections ever since. That is the inherent nature of a state, not a perversion of it.
The film also showed how these business interests cut across the boundaries of individual presidencies. It does not matter who is in office, Republican or Democrat, liberal or conservative. That is more of a symbolic matter. Behind the illusion of different personalities and disparate ideologies, there lies the same corporate elite making all of the decisions.
The primary argument of the documentary is that the root cause of the financial crisis can be traced back to the period of deregulation of the financial sector inaugurated by Reagan.
First, I think it is important to note that deregulation began under Carter's presidency, not Reagan. Volcker, who they noted was a VP for Chase Manhattan bank (but failed to mention was the chairman of the Federal Reserve from 1979 into the 80s, and thus responsible for many of policies they decried), was appointed by Carter. Once again, individual presidencies do not matter. It was the VP of a major bank who was really calling the shots.
Second, it is also necessary to remember that financial deregulation was a response to global economic stagnation which set in at the end of the 1960s. It's not like the economy was doing great before hand. Yes, Keynesian strategies prevented any major recessions from occurring, but they did not resolve underlying stagnation (thus, "stagflation") or contribute to any growth. Therefore, financial deregulation cannot be held as a root cause; it itself is a symptom of a broader crisis of overproduction.
This is all in keeping with a general pattern regarding periods of economic stagnation. Such periods are always characterized by a shift in focus from productive activities (which no longer yield good returns) to high finance. And the shift toward financialization is always the nail in the coffin, the thing that leads to ultimate collapse before global economic and political structures are eventually reorganized. It is representative of the attempts of the wealthy elite to try to get as much out of the system as they can before it finally implodes.
Several of the interviewees in Inside Job made a good point: the wealth that was created from the 1980s onward was imaginary: it was not rooted in material or creative processes; it was spun out of thin air (out of debt, actually). This is in keeping with my point in the last paragraph (that dependence on high finance is a last-ditch effort that is chosen when material/creative processes are declining in profitability), but it also illustrates a more general Marxist principle. Marx insisted that economic processes could not be understood apart from material productive relationships. When one forgets that profits, investment, monetary transactions, etc. only occur in relation to production - particularly the manufacturing sector - then one imbues statistics and economic indicators with a power they do not have. For, if material productive processes are faltering, it does not matter how much stock prices are rising or asset values increasing, or income growing. Because wealth can temporarily be spun out of thin air, but only temporarily.
Monday, June 27, 2011
AIDS and the World System
In honor of National HIV Testing Day...
I mentioned before that there is a strong connection between disease and political economic processes. For one thing, disease often follows lines of marginalization and exploitation. Not only does it tend to appear within conditions of poverty (which, let us not forget, is always caused by exploitation), but also among stigmatized populations, in areas where infrastructure has been weakened, where the environment has been degraded due to industrial development, etc. The situation is magnified when certain groups of people become solely associated with a particular disease and attributed all the blame, as a result of their "primitive," "backward," or "sinful" behavior. (AIDS has been branded as a gay disease and a black disease, for example.)
It is also interesting to consider the extent to which patterns of disease are correlated with large-scale economic cycles. For example, it seems more than pure coincidence that the Black Death, one of the largest multi-regional epidemics of disease in history, occurred on the heels of an economic downturn that was the prelude to the one of the greatest periods of economic stagnation the world has yet seen.
It is reasonable to suppose that we are currently headed for a comparable phase of stagnation. (It is more than a simple "recession" or "downturn" or blip on the radar.) So, it is also interesting to consider that the AIDS epidemic came to light near the beginning of this latest period of economic stagnation, which started in the 1970s. Coincidence?
At any rate, it's an interesting thought.
I mentioned before that there is a strong connection between disease and political economic processes. For one thing, disease often follows lines of marginalization and exploitation. Not only does it tend to appear within conditions of poverty (which, let us not forget, is always caused by exploitation), but also among stigmatized populations, in areas where infrastructure has been weakened, where the environment has been degraded due to industrial development, etc. The situation is magnified when certain groups of people become solely associated with a particular disease and attributed all the blame, as a result of their "primitive," "backward," or "sinful" behavior. (AIDS has been branded as a gay disease and a black disease, for example.)
It is also interesting to consider the extent to which patterns of disease are correlated with large-scale economic cycles. For example, it seems more than pure coincidence that the Black Death, one of the largest multi-regional epidemics of disease in history, occurred on the heels of an economic downturn that was the prelude to the one of the greatest periods of economic stagnation the world has yet seen.
It is reasonable to suppose that we are currently headed for a comparable phase of stagnation. (It is more than a simple "recession" or "downturn" or blip on the radar.) So, it is also interesting to consider that the AIDS epidemic came to light near the beginning of this latest period of economic stagnation, which started in the 1970s. Coincidence?
At any rate, it's an interesting thought.
Labels:
disease,
economic cycles,
health,
inequality,
poverty
Friday, June 3, 2011
The Economy Will Not Recover
People keep talking about "economic recovery," and economists of all stripes have been monitoring micro-level indicators of growth to forecast when or how this will occur.
Stories like this seem to lend more credence to the view that we are at a point of deep structural crisis, and eventual long-term transformation.
Stories like this seem to lend more credence to the view that we are at a point of deep structural crisis, and eventual long-term transformation.
Labels:
economic crisis,
economic cycles,
economic recovery
Thursday, May 26, 2011
The Crisis of Overproduction
One of Marx's most fundamental propositions is that capitalism is based on a number of contradictions that limit its potential for unfettered growth, and ultimately destabilize the entire system.
1. One of the primary ways by which capitalists profit is by keeping wages low. However, lowering wages also reduces demand for the goods that are produced. Thus, the tendency to try to minimize wages and to maximize demand are contradictory.
2. Investment in new productive technology, while increasng the efficiency of the production process and initially raising profits, actually lowers the rate of profit. This is because profit is the realization of surplus value, and surplus value derives from the ability to obtain human labor in excess of what one is paying for the labor through wages. Thus, surplus value and profit are directly dependent on human labor. Introducing new technology into the production process reduces the proportion of human labor embedded in the price and cost of each object produced. This means that it is more difficult to accumulate surplus labor at the same rate. The reduction in the rate of profit can be forestalled through the creation of monopolies (for example, through copyrights), which allows one to keep prices high despite lowered production costs. However, monopolies can only be sustained for so long.
These contradictions that are particular to capitalism derive from principles pertinant to the accumulation of wealth in general (capitalist or non-capitalist). Recall the primary principle that continued investment in profitable enterprises decreases their profitability. Essentially (though this is a slight over-simplication) when one expands an enterprise (by re-investing accumulated surplus capital), then one risks undermining advantages on both the input and output end of the production process:
-Increasing the supply of goods that one is providing drives down prices
-Increasing the demand for inputs drives up the cost of the inputs
Thus, material expansion endangers profitability from both ends. When one accumulates more capital than one can profitably re-invest (i.e. when such a re-investment would enlarge the enterprise beyond the point of profitability) the result is a crisis of overaccumulation. One has two options. Either one can find other outlets for investment (other enterprises, financial speculation, public works and philanthropy - the latter also working as a means to cultivate political power), or one can actually continue to invest the accumulated capital and expand the enterprise. If the latter course is chosen, then a crisis of overaccumulation will become a crisis of overproduction. In a crisis of overproduction, the investment of excess capital in material expansion beyond the point of profitability results in a surfeit of goods produced in relation to demand.
Such is the situation the world now finds itself in. The post-WW2 era was a period of rapid economic acceleration and expansion. The widespread incorporation of mechanized production and assembly line production techniques, in addition to the rise of the transnational corporation, afforded rapid economic growth and productivity increases to the world's industrial powers, most notably the U.S., Western Europe, and Japan. By the end of the 1960s, however, this economic expansion was already becoming a crisis of overproduction.
One response to the overproduction crisis has been the use of Keynesian deficit-spending tactics. This has been most prominent in the United States, even in the 1980s when Reagan ratched up military spending. However, many countries in the world are now saddled with massive amounts of debt, so it is certainly not a strategy confined to the U.S.
Another approach has been to divert investment away from production and toward financial speculation. This began toward the end of the 1970s and particularly with the advent of Reagan-Thatcherism. Results of this strategy have included: Third World economic collapse and debt crises, bubbles, bubbles, and burst bubbles. The events of the past few years have, I think, made it very clear that financial speculation is not a path to sustainable prosperity.
History suggests that a crisis of overproduction of the scale now plaguing the world economy cannot necessarily be "overcome." Instead, a certain level of systemic collapse and reorganization is necessary. And this takes a long, long time. We might have to deal with global economic depression for the rest of our lifetime. Enjoy the ride!
1. One of the primary ways by which capitalists profit is by keeping wages low. However, lowering wages also reduces demand for the goods that are produced. Thus, the tendency to try to minimize wages and to maximize demand are contradictory.
2. Investment in new productive technology, while increasng the efficiency of the production process and initially raising profits, actually lowers the rate of profit. This is because profit is the realization of surplus value, and surplus value derives from the ability to obtain human labor in excess of what one is paying for the labor through wages. Thus, surplus value and profit are directly dependent on human labor. Introducing new technology into the production process reduces the proportion of human labor embedded in the price and cost of each object produced. This means that it is more difficult to accumulate surplus labor at the same rate. The reduction in the rate of profit can be forestalled through the creation of monopolies (for example, through copyrights), which allows one to keep prices high despite lowered production costs. However, monopolies can only be sustained for so long.
These contradictions that are particular to capitalism derive from principles pertinant to the accumulation of wealth in general (capitalist or non-capitalist). Recall the primary principle that continued investment in profitable enterprises decreases their profitability. Essentially (though this is a slight over-simplication) when one expands an enterprise (by re-investing accumulated surplus capital), then one risks undermining advantages on both the input and output end of the production process:
-Increasing the supply of goods that one is providing drives down prices
-Increasing the demand for inputs drives up the cost of the inputs
Thus, material expansion endangers profitability from both ends. When one accumulates more capital than one can profitably re-invest (i.e. when such a re-investment would enlarge the enterprise beyond the point of profitability) the result is a crisis of overaccumulation. One has two options. Either one can find other outlets for investment (other enterprises, financial speculation, public works and philanthropy - the latter also working as a means to cultivate political power), or one can actually continue to invest the accumulated capital and expand the enterprise. If the latter course is chosen, then a crisis of overaccumulation will become a crisis of overproduction. In a crisis of overproduction, the investment of excess capital in material expansion beyond the point of profitability results in a surfeit of goods produced in relation to demand.
Such is the situation the world now finds itself in. The post-WW2 era was a period of rapid economic acceleration and expansion. The widespread incorporation of mechanized production and assembly line production techniques, in addition to the rise of the transnational corporation, afforded rapid economic growth and productivity increases to the world's industrial powers, most notably the U.S., Western Europe, and Japan. By the end of the 1960s, however, this economic expansion was already becoming a crisis of overproduction.
One response to the overproduction crisis has been the use of Keynesian deficit-spending tactics. This has been most prominent in the United States, even in the 1980s when Reagan ratched up military spending. However, many countries in the world are now saddled with massive amounts of debt, so it is certainly not a strategy confined to the U.S.
Another approach has been to divert investment away from production and toward financial speculation. This began toward the end of the 1970s and particularly with the advent of Reagan-Thatcherism. Results of this strategy have included: Third World economic collapse and debt crises, bubbles, bubbles, and burst bubbles. The events of the past few years have, I think, made it very clear that financial speculation is not a path to sustainable prosperity.
History suggests that a crisis of overproduction of the scale now plaguing the world economy cannot necessarily be "overcome." Instead, a certain level of systemic collapse and reorganization is necessary. And this takes a long, long time. We might have to deal with global economic depression for the rest of our lifetime. Enjoy the ride!
Wednesday, May 25, 2011
Book Review: The Boom and The Bubble
I realized that I have repeatedly referred to the global crisis of overproduction, yet I do not think I have ever discussed the concept of overproduction in any detail. To start, I recommend the book The Boom and The Bubble: The U.S. in the World Economy by Robert Brenner. Brenner traces the history of the current crisis of overproduction and describes the way in which it has proceeded throughout the past few decades. I find that it is a very useful resource for understanding recent economic history. However, Brenner neglects any consideration of overproduction from a theoretical standpoint. That is what I plan to accomplish in my next post.
Just in brief, though, I will summarize a couple of Brenner's main points. First, he argues that the position of the U.S. in the world economy is such that its patterns of deficit spending and high levels of internal consumption have been the lynchpin of global economy. Enervated by overproduction, the economy has come to depend on U.S.-manufactured demand to prop up the demand side of the supply-demand equation. Second, Brenner contends that the global economy, as a whole, has been stagnant since the late 1960s. Apparent economic growth in any given country has only come in the form of bubbles, and directly at the expense of other countries, via manipulations of currency value, exchange rates, interest rates, etc. In essence, there has been no real economic growth for four decades.
Just in brief, though, I will summarize a couple of Brenner's main points. First, he argues that the position of the U.S. in the world economy is such that its patterns of deficit spending and high levels of internal consumption have been the lynchpin of global economy. Enervated by overproduction, the economy has come to depend on U.S.-manufactured demand to prop up the demand side of the supply-demand equation. Second, Brenner contends that the global economy, as a whole, has been stagnant since the late 1960s. Apparent economic growth in any given country has only come in the form of bubbles, and directly at the expense of other countries, via manipulations of currency value, exchange rates, interest rates, etc. In essence, there has been no real economic growth for four decades.
Sunday, March 6, 2011
Summary
Now that I have set out most of the main premises of my Marxist worldview, which I will be elaborating in future posts, probably with more attention to specific current events, I thought it would be a good idea to summarize the ideas I have presented so far before moving on.
- Accumulation of wealth, in general, occurs through relationships of exploitation and the limitation of competition (often via use of state mechanisms). Accumulation of wealth is always a redistribution of wealth, and as such, it strains the very system by which it occurs, rendering it unsustainable for any particular individual or corporation in the long run.
- Power is not a "thing" that one "has" but a characteristic of relationships (acting upon another's actions). Most forms of power are decentralized and present in any type of social relationship. Sovereignty is a more centralized form of power that adheres between an institution wielding legitimate use of violence and enforcement of law, and those upon whom the legitimate violence and rule of law are exercised. Nominally, the former is "the state," although the state is actually a tool employed by the dominant groups of society.
- The primary defining characteristic of capitalism is wage labor.
- Wage labor allows for large-scale organization of production and investment in technology that creates "economies of scale."
- When production occurs at such a large scale and is simultaneously oriented only toward profit-making goals rather than the actual societal need, over-production is the inevitable result.
- To overcome crises of over-production, capitalists must create demand (results: excessive marketing and advertising, constantly outmoded technology and outdated fashions, a consumerist lifestyle, state deficit spending, extension of credit, increasing public and personal debt).
- However, the ultimate result of over-production is decreasing profitability of the manufacturing sector and economic stagnation, as well as waste on a large scale.
- For example, as we have all seen, U.S. deficit spending and the stock-market and housing bubbles created by extension of credit were not ultimately able to overcome the global crisis of over-production and economic stagnation that emerged in the late 1960s. It only postponed the inevitable and made the fall much more drastic.
- Since the late 1960s, any period of economic growth in one country has been accomplished primarily through the manipulation of exchange rates and other monetary policy (rather than resolving the global crisis of over-production) and, thus, has occurred directly at the expense of all the others.
- Under capitalism, the condition of wage labor constituting the basis of value provides a point of intersection between sovereign power (self-interested, territorial, focused on wealth and resources) and governmental power (oriented toward the management and cultivation of the life, productivity, and health of populations). Governmental power relationships have greatly expanded, encompassing more areas of life, and have been appropriated to a limited degree by the state. Simultaneously, life itself has come to constitute a basis of sovereignty, whereas previously people were only encountered as objects of secondary importance to territory and resources.
- Thus, under capitalism, life itself has become a grounds of political struggle and power. (For example, the issue of abortion and defining when life begins.)
- The profitability of capitalist enterprise requires cheap inputs.
- This was initially provided by the emergence of a class of landless, unemployed peasants (dispossessed of their land) whose labor could be exploited. This was followed by the large-scale use of slave labor in the American colonies.
- Later, capitalists were forced to turn their attention toward procuring cheaper raw materials. This was achieved via colonization of the rest of the world where these resources were located.
- More recently, there has been a swing back toward the pursuit of cheap labor, as well as cheap "light" manufactured goods as inputs for more "value-added" industry. This is accomplished by using "neocolonial" relationships of exploitation to open the markets of formerly colonized nations to multi-national corporations. This also serves the purpose of creating additional markets for commodities in the face of global over-production.
- These are the relationships of exploitation that characterize capitalist accumulation of wealth.
- The end result is an increasing gap between the wealthiest nations and the poorest.
- These realities are concealed from popular awareness by a number of ideologies that uphold the social order.
- Social contract ideology promotes the belief that states have a power of their own, apart from dominant groups, and by consent of all the citizens. In so far as states are seen as the real locus of power, rather than dominant groups, all attempts to limit or combat power are errantly directed at the state, such as trying to "reduce the size of government."
- Social contract ideology also encourages people to view economies as nationally bounded, and to assume that state policies (or lack thereof) are the root cause of economic growth and recession. Thus, economic crises are not seen as resulting from inherent flaws in a global system, but as something which can be "fixed" and permanently avoided through the proper state action (or inaction, depending on one's perspective).
- Neoliberal ideology supports the belief that the system is fair, the playing field is level, and any inequalities result from "natural" inadequacies and moral deficiencies. Thus, poverty is accepted as the just due of the unworthy. It is not the consequence of exploitation or an inherently unjust system.
Saturday, March 5, 2011
Accumulation of Wealth
I have already discussed some of the inherent contradictions of the capitalist system, but I think it is important to identify some more general characteristics of the accumulation of wealth, based on historical patterns, that may shed some light on those that pertain specifically to capitalism (the items in my list below link to previous posts so that a comparison may be made).
**By accumulation of wealth, I mean accumulation far beyond what one can produce by oneself or among a freely associating group of people, given whatever technology is available at the time.
1. It occurs at the expense of others.
2. It is generally dependent on some form of state support.
3. It is dependent on limitations to competition.
4. It is always unsustainable in the long run.
-The greater the economic expansion, the more strain is put on the system, and thus the bigger and faster the subsequent collapse
5. Continuing to invest in a profitable enterprise ultimately reduces its profitability.
6. Expansion occurs primarily via:
-Strategic monopolies
-The debt of other people
7. Contrary to neoliberal ideology:
-Success derives from a mixture of relative initial weakness and historical accident
-The most successful enterprises lose their adaptability in the process of attaining their success and ultimately fail
-Unfettered competition generally leads to decreased profitability for everyone
**By accumulation of wealth, I mean accumulation far beyond what one can produce by oneself or among a freely associating group of people, given whatever technology is available at the time.
1. It occurs at the expense of others.
2. It is generally dependent on some form of state support.
3. It is dependent on limitations to competition.
4. It is always unsustainable in the long run.
-The greater the economic expansion, the more strain is put on the system, and thus the bigger and faster the subsequent collapse
5. Continuing to invest in a profitable enterprise ultimately reduces its profitability.
6. Expansion occurs primarily via:
-Strategic monopolies
-The debt of other people
7. Contrary to neoliberal ideology:
-Success derives from a mixture of relative initial weakness and historical accident
-The most successful enterprises lose their adaptability in the process of attaining their success and ultimately fail
-Unfettered competition generally leads to decreased profitability for everyone
Labels:
competition,
economic crisis,
economic cycles,
profitability,
wealth
Thursday, February 24, 2011
Capitalism is Inherently Unstable
One of Marx's most fundamental arguments is that capitalism is characterized by a number of inherent contradictions. Such as:
1. Increasing investment in technology reduces the rate of accumulation of surplus value (the amount of human labor in excess of the wages actually paid), and hence, profit. This is because technology reduces the proportion of human labor embedded in each commodity. Also, as technology develops, production cycles become ever more rapid. This means that there is a greater likelihood that any given technology will become competitively obsolete before the capitalist is able to recoup the cost of the investment (let alone profit from it).
2. The profit motive seeks to lower wages and expand demand. In other words, workers have less purchasing power, but are expected to buy more.
As a result of these factors, capitalism is subject to continuous cycles of expansion and contraction. Crises are inevitable.
In addition, for any person who wishes to start a capitalist enterprise, the risks and costs of initial investment become more prohibitive as capitalism develops, for the following reasons:
1. Increasing centralization of capital (monopolies, huge corporate conglomerates)
2. Expanding state interventions (subsidies, credit expansion, inflation)
3. Increasing personal, public, and private indebtedness (since personal and public "deficit spending" is encouraged in order to prop up demand)
State interventions and debt-fueled booms (bubbles) can only slow down the decline of capitalist accumulation for so long.
Ultimately, capitalism is difficult to sustain because, while the total value (corresponding to the total number of hours of labor available) remains fixed, an increasingly small number of people are enabled to draw upon a larger proportion of the pool, thus straining the entire system. If the pool is fixed there must be limits to the accumulation of wealth, while capitalist accumulation constantly strives to push beyond these limits. Capitalists try to sustain their profits in the face of this reality by driving unnecessary consumption and massive indebtedness: obviously not a viable solution in the long run.
Thus, capitalism is ultimately unsustainable.
1. Increasing investment in technology reduces the rate of accumulation of surplus value (the amount of human labor in excess of the wages actually paid), and hence, profit. This is because technology reduces the proportion of human labor embedded in each commodity. Also, as technology develops, production cycles become ever more rapid. This means that there is a greater likelihood that any given technology will become competitively obsolete before the capitalist is able to recoup the cost of the investment (let alone profit from it).
2. The profit motive seeks to lower wages and expand demand. In other words, workers have less purchasing power, but are expected to buy more.
As a result of these factors, capitalism is subject to continuous cycles of expansion and contraction. Crises are inevitable.
In addition, for any person who wishes to start a capitalist enterprise, the risks and costs of initial investment become more prohibitive as capitalism develops, for the following reasons:
- the shortening cycles of production mentioned above
- globally organized vertical integration (to be most efficient, you must have all stages of the production process under your control)
- following from the quickening pace of production cycles, the increasing importance of Research & Development (constantly finding new ways to out-do competitors) also raises the investment costs and potential risks (unfruitful research)
1. Increasing centralization of capital (monopolies, huge corporate conglomerates)
2. Expanding state interventions (subsidies, credit expansion, inflation)
3. Increasing personal, public, and private indebtedness (since personal and public "deficit spending" is encouraged in order to prop up demand)
State interventions and debt-fueled booms (bubbles) can only slow down the decline of capitalist accumulation for so long.
Ultimately, capitalism is difficult to sustain because, while the total value (corresponding to the total number of hours of labor available) remains fixed, an increasingly small number of people are enabled to draw upon a larger proportion of the pool, thus straining the entire system. If the pool is fixed there must be limits to the accumulation of wealth, while capitalist accumulation constantly strives to push beyond these limits. Capitalists try to sustain their profits in the face of this reality by driving unnecessary consumption and massive indebtedness: obviously not a viable solution in the long run.
Thus, capitalism is ultimately unsustainable.
Sunday, February 20, 2011
Capitalism is Inherently Global
National boundaries do not represent the natural limits of capitalism. All economic activity is ultimately determined by global market forces; the state merely provides regional constraints for global competition.
The actions of one state affects all others. For example, accumulation of wealth in the industrialized core only occurs at the expense of other nations, through relations of exploitation. Primarily, these relations involve unequal trade, creating dependency through specialization, and control of the economic policies of underdeveloped nations by the industrialized core via transnational organizations such as the World Bank and IMF. I will discuss this in much greater detail later. However, the most important point to bear in mind for the moment is that the global political-economic system is structured in such a way that resources and capital are constantly flowing from poorer countries to richer ones, creating an ever widening gap between rich and poor.
Consequently, limited motion is possible within the global hierarchy of wealth. For most underdeveloped nations, increased integration into the world market has resulted in increased poverty. For "semi-peripheral nations" (the handful of countries whose fortune lies somewhere in between the wealthy, industrial core and the destitute Third World), some movement in either direction is possible, but "economic miracles" are rare and often fragile. Socialism/communism, in so far as it limits integration into the global economy, protects nations from such exploitation, to a certain degree. Historically, if it has had any effect, it has mitigated the impoverishment of countries relative to others of an initially similar position in the global hierarchy of wealth. (Usually, the success or failure of socialist states is measured against the standard of wealth enjoyed by the industrialized core; however, this ignores the fact that the wealth of similarly positioned but non-socialist states has steadily decreased against the core. Hence, the comparison needs to be made against these latter states.) Furthermore, on a domestic level, the poorest classes have generally fared better within socialist nations than within non-socialist ones.
Another example of the way in which the economic policies and fortunes of one state affects all others is the fact that within the industrialized core, nations must constantly compete with one another to retain or expand their share of the world's wealth. Accumulation of wealth in one country always occurs at the expense of others. Since the decline of manufacturing profitability in the 1970s, economic growth has occurred primarily via manipulation of exchange rates and monetary policy. Thus, for the past few decades, all boom cycles have occurred directly at the expense of other countries rather than by increasing productivity and profitability. In this zero-sum game of global tug-of-war, upturns are short-lived and frequent crises are inevitable.
The actions of one state affects all others. For example, accumulation of wealth in the industrialized core only occurs at the expense of other nations, through relations of exploitation. Primarily, these relations involve unequal trade, creating dependency through specialization, and control of the economic policies of underdeveloped nations by the industrialized core via transnational organizations such as the World Bank and IMF. I will discuss this in much greater detail later. However, the most important point to bear in mind for the moment is that the global political-economic system is structured in such a way that resources and capital are constantly flowing from poorer countries to richer ones, creating an ever widening gap between rich and poor.
Consequently, limited motion is possible within the global hierarchy of wealth. For most underdeveloped nations, increased integration into the world market has resulted in increased poverty. For "semi-peripheral nations" (the handful of countries whose fortune lies somewhere in between the wealthy, industrial core and the destitute Third World), some movement in either direction is possible, but "economic miracles" are rare and often fragile. Socialism/communism, in so far as it limits integration into the global economy, protects nations from such exploitation, to a certain degree. Historically, if it has had any effect, it has mitigated the impoverishment of countries relative to others of an initially similar position in the global hierarchy of wealth. (Usually, the success or failure of socialist states is measured against the standard of wealth enjoyed by the industrialized core; however, this ignores the fact that the wealth of similarly positioned but non-socialist states has steadily decreased against the core. Hence, the comparison needs to be made against these latter states.) Furthermore, on a domestic level, the poorest classes have generally fared better within socialist nations than within non-socialist ones.
Another example of the way in which the economic policies and fortunes of one state affects all others is the fact that within the industrialized core, nations must constantly compete with one another to retain or expand their share of the world's wealth. Accumulation of wealth in one country always occurs at the expense of others. Since the decline of manufacturing profitability in the 1970s, economic growth has occurred primarily via manipulation of exchange rates and monetary policy. Thus, for the past few decades, all boom cycles have occurred directly at the expense of other countries rather than by increasing productivity and profitability. In this zero-sum game of global tug-of-war, upturns are short-lived and frequent crises are inevitable.
Labels:
economic cycles,
exploitation,
global markets,
globalization,
poverty,
socialism,
wealth
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)