I have elaborated on science, and now I would like to elaborate a bit on the state. It got a nice pummeling from me a couple of posts ago, when I claimed it was essentially a tool of violence wielded by capitalist interests. Does this put me along side "small government" libertarians?
Maybe in some respects. But here are all the areas where I think libertarians are flat out wrong:
1. Libertarians do not view the state as a servant of the capitalist class; they believe it is in an independent source of power (by which capitalists may actually be oppressed);
2. Libertarians completely misunderstand the nature of capitalism. They believe it is primarily characterized by free markets and private enterprise, when it is actually characterized by wage labor and monopolization of production and, in fact, both limits the the freedom of the market and subsidizes enterprise (through use of the state, of course). Libertarians tend to see these things as "corruption" rather than the inherent nature of the system.
3. It follows that libertarians believe if the extent of the state were limited, free markets would flourish and the market would more rationally and efficiently organize society than the state. They do not realize the beast we are dealing with, and that eliminating government agencies would be akin to simply cutting off one of its limb (with the possibility of regeneration).
4. Libertarians accept without question all aspects of liberal/neoliberal ideology: the sacredness of the individual, the rationale of the social contract, the principle of "liberty" embedded in "democratic societies" (whatever liberty and democracy mean in actual practice...), and the ability of all people to be successful if they just try hard enough.
5. Regarding that last point, libertarians are totally blind to the inequalities that are built into the system. They seem to think the playing field is level, and that everyone could be a millionare if they just worked sufficiently hard (maybe they even take it for granted that there will always be people naturally "lazy" enough to take all the undesirable, low-paying jobs).
In essense, libertarians buy into all the myths and ideologies of the modern social order, probably more than anyone else, and simply try to make reality conform to those myths. What they really need to do is think more critically about what is actually going on.
There is one more significant way in which I diverge from libertarians, the explanation of which will entail that I contradict my two-posts-ago comments somewhat... which I think is totally healthy behavior. Yes, I believe that the state exists at the behest of the capitalist class and that it always ultimately serves capitalist interests. That is vitally important to remember because pinning one's hopes on the state is a risky business (as many of the Russian revolutionaries discovered). BUT, under very narrow and circumscribed circumstances, eliminating any longer-term perspective, it has its benefits.
Generally, once again if one is only thinking in the short-term and within the bounds of the current system, state management of social services is more beneficial than complete privatization. This holds true for education, health care, transportation, and would likely also hold for financial services if such a thing were ever attempted (it won't be). This is the case because the people who are actually involved in the administration of these programs and services cannot profit in the same way as those who are more indirectly involved. It ensures standards, quality controls, and more or less universal accessibility (often more towards the "less" end though...). And often the people who directly provide the services are knowledgable and driven by the noblest of intentions (not profit). On the other hand, when the profit-motive is directly involved in the provision of services, the consequences are often disasterous. Scams abound, unqualified people jump on the bandwagon, and disparities in quality widen (thus reinforcing existing social inequalities). The ability to profit brings out the worst of human qualities, not the best, as many libertarian types and others insist. But isn't government wasteful and inefficient, they counter? Everything is wasteful and inefficient; that is the nature of bureaucracy, whether public or private. The arena of education, in particular, demonstrates very desicively that public management is by no means less efficient or less effective than private management; to the contrary, public schools often do a better job - particularly with the challenges they are given - than private schools. As I have mentioned in previous posts, the supposed "crisis" of American education is a fabrication of political/economic interest groups.
So, if the only two options I am given are state control within the framework of the current system, and privatization within the framework of the current system, in most cases I would prefer state control. But that is like a slave choosing the house over the fields. I would REALLY prefer not to be enslaved.
Showing posts with label privatization. Show all posts
Showing posts with label privatization. Show all posts
Wednesday, November 23, 2011
Why Libertarians Are Wrong
Labels:
ideology,
libertarianism,
privatization,
the state
Thursday, September 15, 2011
The Education Industry
Since the crisis of overproduction set in, capitalist interests have been scrambling to exploit any last bit of potentially exploitable territory, seeking to find some source of water amid a major drought. The arena of education, both public and private, has been one such source of profit throughout the past couple decades. Who has "made out"? Just to name a few...
-Textbook Companies: Constantly churning out new editions and taking advantage of the ever-changing fads of school reform; defining curricula and making arrangements at the state level in order to cultivate monopolies
-Testing Companies: Hugely benefiting from NCLB's mandates for frequent assessment; offering increasingly more extensive and expensive test prep services
-Private school management and charter school chains: taking advantage of the availability of public funds; in some cases, mirroring what happened in the financial sector, individuals have been able to make out like bandits while their schools fall apart.
-Private institutions of higher education: accused of marketing programs to people who are unlikely to finish, encouraging them to take out loans, not fulfilling what they have promised in their educational offerings, and then leaving them with massive debt
In fact, both private and public institutions of higher education are guilty of promoting student loans and debt, while churning out more degrees than there is a market for (and making the degrees value-less).
[The more I think about it, the more capitalism seems like a sort of weed, which ends up spreading everywhere and choking out all other life. Nothing is safe! Not even education.]
The above examples just happen to illustrate many of the primary characteristics and tendencies of capitalism:
-an endless chain of fads and perpetual obsolescence
-monopolies
-a parasitic relationship with the state
-individual gain at the expense of everyone else
-multiplication of debt
-Textbook Companies: Constantly churning out new editions and taking advantage of the ever-changing fads of school reform; defining curricula and making arrangements at the state level in order to cultivate monopolies
-Testing Companies: Hugely benefiting from NCLB's mandates for frequent assessment; offering increasingly more extensive and expensive test prep services
-Private school management and charter school chains: taking advantage of the availability of public funds; in some cases, mirroring what happened in the financial sector, individuals have been able to make out like bandits while their schools fall apart.
-Private institutions of higher education: accused of marketing programs to people who are unlikely to finish, encouraging them to take out loans, not fulfilling what they have promised in their educational offerings, and then leaving them with massive debt
In fact, both private and public institutions of higher education are guilty of promoting student loans and debt, while churning out more degrees than there is a market for (and making the degrees value-less).
[The more I think about it, the more capitalism seems like a sort of weed, which ends up spreading everywhere and choking out all other life. Nothing is safe! Not even education.]
The above examples just happen to illustrate many of the primary characteristics and tendencies of capitalism:
-an endless chain of fads and perpetual obsolescence
-monopolies
-a parasitic relationship with the state
-individual gain at the expense of everyone else
-multiplication of debt
Labels:
debt,
education,
monopolies,
overproduction,
privatization
Wednesday, September 14, 2011
The New Era of Education Reform
By the time that President Bush took office in 2001, the desire to raise achievement for all students (born out of A Nation at Risk) still remained, but with a distinct tendency to avoid any discussion of what students should know in any subject (a result of the history standards controversy). To satisfy both of these conflicting demands, reformers began to concentrate exclusively on skills - primarily reading, and secondarily mathematics.
The demand for higher standards was replaced by the demand for greater accountability, and this was to be understood solely in terms of test scores in reading and mathematics. It was presumed that the performance of districts, schools, and individual teachers could be measured by changes in students' test scores. Of course, this is not the case, for a large number of reasons, many relating to the nature of the tests themselves. The most fundamental underlying assumption was that all students could succeed given the right teachers and schools. Social structural factors, in the end, did not matter. This, of course, is neoliberal ideology. Social structural factors will always have primary causality, and school-related factors can only have marginal mitigating effects.
The accountability movement joined forces with the school choice movement and the resulting love-child was Bush's No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB). Under NCLB, school progress is measured by student performance on state-designed tests in reading and math. Those who fail to meet "Adequate Yearly Progress" face sactions: students may receive vouchers to attend other schools, for instance, or the school may be "restructured" and placed under different (possibly private) management. One may note that states can set the bar for "proficiency" wherever they want, so that the test results are essentially meaningless, and that simply testing certain literacy and numeracy skills is not an adequate measure of quality education. Hence, NCLB encourages states to lower their standards and teacher and schools to narrow their curriculum to focus on basic skills and test-taking strategies.
However, the greatest implication of NCLB lies in the types of sanctions it employs. NCLB is basically a covert strategy for privatizing the education system. Consider: 1) the bar set by NCLB is so high that only the highest-achieving schools in the wealthiest and most homogenous locales could ever reach it (and even that is not certain);by 2014 nearly every school will be considered "failing" and 2) the consequences for "failing" involve the use of vouchers and the transfer of public funds to private organizations. The reason why just about every school will be considered "failing" by 2014 is that at that time all schools are supposed to reach 100% proficiency for all measured subgroups (race-based and ability-based). However, one subgroup - English-language learners - are defined precisely by their failure on tests of literacy. Any English-language learner who attains a level of proficiency will pulled out of the English-language learner subgroup. Likewise for those with "special needs." NCLB is not measure progress at all!
Obama has largely continued the program established under Bush's presidency. He has accessorized it with some similarly-minded carrot-wielding programs, like Race to the Top. In Race to the Top, certain states - the "winners" - receive extra funding for their schools. And the basis for this vital funding is arbitrary criteria assigned arbitrary weightings, with a little bit of flawed statistical reasoning thrown into the mix, and topped with subjective ratings. Obama and his appointees to the Department of Education continue to voice their support for school choice, competition, charter schools, and teacher accountability.
Going back to what I claimed are the primary roles served by education in a capitalist society, it is reasonable to ask, how does the project of privatization - essentially eroding the public school system - serve those ends? First, education continues to be subsidized. In fact, with programs like Race to the Top, more federal money is being doled out. True, privatization and choice seem to undermine the assimilative role of education, yet they also stand as affirmations of neoliberal ideology, and work as effective means to increase social stratification. Furthermore, with its premise that education reform is about schools and teachers, and not about poverty and society, the new school reforms have absorbed the efforts and directed the actions of those who wish to change society, forcing them to do so set within certain bounds that do not disrupt the social hierarchy at all.
But mostly I believe it is about unions. There has been a concerted anti-union effort throughout the entire WW2 era, and it has kept the United States economically competitive with other industrialized nations, who have stronger unions and/or higher wages. However, the teachers' unions are now one of the most powerful workers' groups (which says more about that state of unions in general than anything else). Most privatization schemes, be they vouchers, charter schools, "restructuring," etc. undercut teachers' unions. Focus on teacher effectiveness (assigning teachers sole responsibility for student achievement when social factors are far more significant), proposals for merit-based pay, attacks on tenure, the claim teachers should be fired more easily, the de-professionalization of teaching and insistence that there should be no requirements for entering the field - all are direct swipes at teachers' unions.
One thing is certain. The "biggest losers" in the new era of reform, with all of its haphazard tinkering with poor and urban school districts, is the most disadvantaged students in the country.
The demand for higher standards was replaced by the demand for greater accountability, and this was to be understood solely in terms of test scores in reading and mathematics. It was presumed that the performance of districts, schools, and individual teachers could be measured by changes in students' test scores. Of course, this is not the case, for a large number of reasons, many relating to the nature of the tests themselves. The most fundamental underlying assumption was that all students could succeed given the right teachers and schools. Social structural factors, in the end, did not matter. This, of course, is neoliberal ideology. Social structural factors will always have primary causality, and school-related factors can only have marginal mitigating effects.
The accountability movement joined forces with the school choice movement and the resulting love-child was Bush's No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB). Under NCLB, school progress is measured by student performance on state-designed tests in reading and math. Those who fail to meet "Adequate Yearly Progress" face sactions: students may receive vouchers to attend other schools, for instance, or the school may be "restructured" and placed under different (possibly private) management. One may note that states can set the bar for "proficiency" wherever they want, so that the test results are essentially meaningless, and that simply testing certain literacy and numeracy skills is not an adequate measure of quality education. Hence, NCLB encourages states to lower their standards and teacher and schools to narrow their curriculum to focus on basic skills and test-taking strategies.
However, the greatest implication of NCLB lies in the types of sanctions it employs. NCLB is basically a covert strategy for privatizing the education system. Consider: 1) the bar set by NCLB is so high that only the highest-achieving schools in the wealthiest and most homogenous locales could ever reach it (and even that is not certain);by 2014 nearly every school will be considered "failing" and 2) the consequences for "failing" involve the use of vouchers and the transfer of public funds to private organizations. The reason why just about every school will be considered "failing" by 2014 is that at that time all schools are supposed to reach 100% proficiency for all measured subgroups (race-based and ability-based). However, one subgroup - English-language learners - are defined precisely by their failure on tests of literacy. Any English-language learner who attains a level of proficiency will pulled out of the English-language learner subgroup. Likewise for those with "special needs." NCLB is not measure progress at all!
Obama has largely continued the program established under Bush's presidency. He has accessorized it with some similarly-minded carrot-wielding programs, like Race to the Top. In Race to the Top, certain states - the "winners" - receive extra funding for their schools. And the basis for this vital funding is arbitrary criteria assigned arbitrary weightings, with a little bit of flawed statistical reasoning thrown into the mix, and topped with subjective ratings. Obama and his appointees to the Department of Education continue to voice their support for school choice, competition, charter schools, and teacher accountability.
Going back to what I claimed are the primary roles served by education in a capitalist society, it is reasonable to ask, how does the project of privatization - essentially eroding the public school system - serve those ends? First, education continues to be subsidized. In fact, with programs like Race to the Top, more federal money is being doled out. True, privatization and choice seem to undermine the assimilative role of education, yet they also stand as affirmations of neoliberal ideology, and work as effective means to increase social stratification. Furthermore, with its premise that education reform is about schools and teachers, and not about poverty and society, the new school reforms have absorbed the efforts and directed the actions of those who wish to change society, forcing them to do so set within certain bounds that do not disrupt the social hierarchy at all.
But mostly I believe it is about unions. There has been a concerted anti-union effort throughout the entire WW2 era, and it has kept the United States economically competitive with other industrialized nations, who have stronger unions and/or higher wages. However, the teachers' unions are now one of the most powerful workers' groups (which says more about that state of unions in general than anything else). Most privatization schemes, be they vouchers, charter schools, "restructuring," etc. undercut teachers' unions. Focus on teacher effectiveness (assigning teachers sole responsibility for student achievement when social factors are far more significant), proposals for merit-based pay, attacks on tenure, the claim teachers should be fired more easily, the de-professionalization of teaching and insistence that there should be no requirements for entering the field - all are direct swipes at teachers' unions.
One thing is certain. The "biggest losers" in the new era of reform, with all of its haphazard tinkering with poor and urban school districts, is the most disadvantaged students in the country.
Monday, September 12, 2011
School Choice is Segregation
At the same time that Brown v. Board of Education, the Elementary and Second Education Act, and A Nation at Risk were shaping the educational landscape, another movement was emerging in opposition to these developments. This counter-movement, premised on ideas of "choice" and privatization, has increasingly sought to undermine the enterprise of public education itself.
The "school choice" movement originated as a means of avoiding desegregation orders, particularly in southern states. It was one loophole in the Brown v. Board of Education ruling. The states/districts employing "choice" programs insisted that they were simply allowing students to decide where they wanted to go to school rather than mandating school assignments and implementing forced bussing. The reality, however, was that they had devised a way of maintaining segregation of the schools.
Later, after the federal government began allocating funds for low-income schools, and after A Nation at Risk salvaged the Department of Education and inaugurated a discussion about national standards, the "school choice" movement morphed into an attempt to undercut the federal government's role in education entirely. "Privatization" and "vouchers" became the buzzwords of the day.
In the 90s the attention started to shift toward charter schools, which are more palatable versions of voucher schools (mainly because public money does not go to religious schools). Charters schools have become a raging fad, and there have been a number of popular books and documentaries (for example, Waiting for Superman) trumpeting the success of these schools.
All flying in the face of the fact that now there is undeniable evidence that voucher systems and charter schools do not do what their advocates claim they do. A handful of charter schools are very good; but most aren't any better than the average public schools, and some are far, far worse. Furthermore, even with non-discriminatory admissions policies and established under a guise of helping the neediest students, charter schools still tend to exclude the most disadvantaged students: either directly in the admissions process or by "weeding them out" after they have enrolled. [For more information about charter schools, vouchers, and school choice, I would recommend the book The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice are Undermining Education by Diane Ravitch (a former proponent of these reforms). It is, at the very least, a much more accurate account of the past few decades of reform than films like Waiting for Superman.]
The reason the "choice" movement has become so successful (in terms of its popularity only) is because it is neoliberal ideology in unadulterated form. "Choice" advocates claim that competition will spur a "race to the top" (shout-outs to Obama's education policy!) in which bad schools "die out" and good schools proliferate. But that is not how free markets work, number one, and number two, capitalism has strangled the freedom of the market. What choice and competition actually do in every case is reinforce the existing socio-economic hierarchy and make it much harder for those on the bottom to "rise up." Choice and competition in the realm of education is a case in point. The real effects of vouchers and privatization of the education system, as far as it has been implemented, are increasing segregation and widening gaps.
In fact, the "school choice" movement is a perfect demonstration of the way in which education is used to reproduce the social order.
The "school choice" movement originated as a means of avoiding desegregation orders, particularly in southern states. It was one loophole in the Brown v. Board of Education ruling. The states/districts employing "choice" programs insisted that they were simply allowing students to decide where they wanted to go to school rather than mandating school assignments and implementing forced bussing. The reality, however, was that they had devised a way of maintaining segregation of the schools.
Later, after the federal government began allocating funds for low-income schools, and after A Nation at Risk salvaged the Department of Education and inaugurated a discussion about national standards, the "school choice" movement morphed into an attempt to undercut the federal government's role in education entirely. "Privatization" and "vouchers" became the buzzwords of the day.
In the 90s the attention started to shift toward charter schools, which are more palatable versions of voucher schools (mainly because public money does not go to religious schools). Charters schools have become a raging fad, and there have been a number of popular books and documentaries (for example, Waiting for Superman) trumpeting the success of these schools.
All flying in the face of the fact that now there is undeniable evidence that voucher systems and charter schools do not do what their advocates claim they do. A handful of charter schools are very good; but most aren't any better than the average public schools, and some are far, far worse. Furthermore, even with non-discriminatory admissions policies and established under a guise of helping the neediest students, charter schools still tend to exclude the most disadvantaged students: either directly in the admissions process or by "weeding them out" after they have enrolled. [For more information about charter schools, vouchers, and school choice, I would recommend the book The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice are Undermining Education by Diane Ravitch (a former proponent of these reforms). It is, at the very least, a much more accurate account of the past few decades of reform than films like Waiting for Superman.]
The reason the "choice" movement has become so successful (in terms of its popularity only) is because it is neoliberal ideology in unadulterated form. "Choice" advocates claim that competition will spur a "race to the top" (shout-outs to Obama's education policy!) in which bad schools "die out" and good schools proliferate. But that is not how free markets work, number one, and number two, capitalism has strangled the freedom of the market. What choice and competition actually do in every case is reinforce the existing socio-economic hierarchy and make it much harder for those on the bottom to "rise up." Choice and competition in the realm of education is a case in point. The real effects of vouchers and privatization of the education system, as far as it has been implemented, are increasing segregation and widening gaps.
In fact, the "school choice" movement is a perfect demonstration of the way in which education is used to reproduce the social order.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)