Sunday, April 22, 2012

The Ideological Foundation of Law

Modern legal discourse and social contract ideology emerged together and are mutually constituting. Social contract ideology posits that members of society are bound together by a “free” contract, the enforcement of which is generally entrusted to the state. According to social contract ideology, however, the state is nothing more than an instrument of the people, who give their consent to allow certain representatives to manage the terms of the contract on everyone’s behalf. What this means, in practice, is that the social contract can only be enforced and protected via these authorized representatives (in other words, the state).  I have emphasized this point before, and it will become important later.  This is also the key to understanding the concept of "rights."  Rights are certain things that are guaranteed to the individual by the state, generally involving protections of property, individual subjectivity (including consciousness, identity, pleasure, and self-determination), and life itself.  Without the state, there are no rights.

Of course, as I have already argued, social contract ideology conceals the non-consensual relations that lie at the heart of modern social formations, and in many ways legitimates exploitation by construing it ideologically as “free contract” (such is the case with wage labor). In fact, the modern contract rests on a theory of personhood in which freedom and formal equality are predicated on ownership of property. Coincident with this view is an elaboration of subjectivity which brings it into realm of "own-able" objects; hence freedom of speech, religion, etc. In this scheme, "equality" and "freedom" mean that one's rights derive (ostensibly) not from social relations and status hierarchies but from an inviolable relation between person and thing. Whatever one owns (however that ownership is reckoned) one is free to dispose of as one wishes. Yet, my parenthetical remark is not entirely parenthetical, as social contract ideology conveniently elides (thereby sanctions) the history and extant structure of property relations.

This is the "loophole" that allows for exploitation. Some people do not have any chance of owning any means of production, and must allow themselves to be exploited via wage labor. In fact, capitalism could not function if everyone owned some (viable) means of production. This fact is obscured by social contract ideology, with its "equality" and "freedom."  In other words, in orienting societal values solely toward the freedoms and privileges inhering in property ownership, questions concerning the distribution of wealth and relations of production become counterposed to the hegemonic sense of moral order, making them all the more difficult to address. Furthermore, it is fitting that this phenomenon has taken root with the rise of global capitalism, a system in which relations between people are represented as relations between things, and in which non-human ("rational") accounts of the social order are privileged.

Monday, April 16, 2012

Marxist Analyses of Law

The simplest definitions of law tend to frame it as a set of rules or norms. There is disagreement about whether or not these rules must be enforced (often by a sovereign) or merely assented to. Marxist interpretations of law tend toward the former (coercion) and often explain legal institutions as an effect or aspect of class struggle. For example, law is necessary to uphold the division of labor, or it is a component of exchange relationships between formally equal owners of property.

Yet, there are many characteristics of law that all of these renderings disregard. It is true that all societies must be governed by rules and norms in order to function, and these may be enforced via individual or collective action. The “rule/norm” definition cannot account for the specificity of modern legal institutions. Similarly, in any society exchange plays a pivotal role in structuring social relations and supporting the division of labor. To simply say that law derives from exchange once again precludes an understanding of distinctly modern social formations. Finally, it is analytically crude to argue that law arises from class struggle, without attempting to describe and explain the manifold ways in which legal institutions have taken on a life of their own, in dialectical relation to political-economic realities.

It is precisely the concept of the dialectic that is absent from many Marxist analyses, though some may pay it lip service. There is a tendency among Marxists to reduce ideological, discursive, and bureaucratic realities to the status of handmaidens of the primary mode of production. However, Marx was quite clear in his discussion of the dialectic that the former elements achieve a certain degree of independence from the material economic order (the “base”), often following their own logics of development and commanding just as much influence over material production as the reverse. What this means is that ideas, discourses, even complex social institutions, may exist in tension with economic necessities. Granted, dominant economic interests will attempt to strategically deploy ideas and discourses, and shape institutions, in ways that are personally beneficial. However, ideas and discourses are appropriated and employed toward a diversity of ends as they circulate, some of which may challenge the social order; and positions within institutions are occupied by a variety of people with different outlooks, abilities, habits, and aspirations.

Hence, it is entirely too simplistic to conclude that law is an effect of class struggle. Law is a way of thinking, talking, and framing events that can be used by anyone (lawyers, judges, politicians, citizens, etc.) for almost any purpose. Many people who employ legal discourses hold an earnest belief in its inherent validity (a “natural law” interpretation). Thus, certain interpretations of the law may influence decision-making even when it runs counter to personal goals. Law cannot be reduced to politics or individual will back by force. It is true that the same legal discourses may be used by people with entirely different political-economic perspectives, and to support widely divergent social aims. But one must not stop there.

Law is not an empty container which can be filled with any kind of “content” whatsoever. Analyses that privilege legal “forms” ignore the significance of particular concepts and discursive themes, such as “human rights,” “equality,” “liberty” and “cruelty.” A critical examination of the modern phenomenon of “law” must begin here. This investigation must include some attention to the centrality of evidence, documentation, and intentionality, as well as the ways in which all of these are tied to a positivist discourse that dominates other realms of modern society.

But one must go further still. It is often noted in passing that the enforcement of law necessitates a sovereign state. This raises a potentially interesting problem (always ignored) as the state is not a concrete, unified object. What elements of our idea of the “state” are actually necessary for the functioning of law? Definitions of the state that focus on territory, in particular, are not able to address the fundamental questions of citizenship that underlie the concept of “rights.”

Finally, there is the question of violence. I agree with those who insist that violence is a necessary and inherent component of law. But what kind of violence, and under what circumstances?

I hope to at least address all of these questions in my next series of posts.

Saturday, March 31, 2012

Ancient Co-optation

I wrote before about how potentially oppositional impulses get co-opted by the system and channeled into activities that maintain the status quo. I noted that I was purposely limiting my discussion to the capitalist era, even though it could be extended beyond that.

For no particular reason whatsoever, I think I will take a stab at a pre-capitalist example. In Europe during the Middle Ages, although the Church had a heavy hand in maintaining the education system, royal powers also learned how to turn it to their own ends. Lawyers, in particular, were inculcated with the view that only royal law (as opposed to divisive feudal legal systems and special merchant law) should be given a place of primacy. Lawyers and other university graduates, who might otherwise consort with the restive bourgeois, were coaxed into the royal bureaucracies, from whence they used their education and skill to enforce royal edicts and maintain the social order.

To me, this is very strikingly similar to the way in which young, educated idealists are currently drawn into government agencies and nonprofit organizations (bureaucratic extensions of government/business).

The question, as always, is… will anything ever change?

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

The Unpopular Mainstream

One interesting dichotomy structuring many sorts of value judgements is that of the “mainstream” versus the “fringe.” I love it. Not only is this another excellent example of linguistic categories – language as action as opposed to representation – but the power plays and strategies entailed by the use of these terms can be absolutely fascinating to observe.

I don’t think it is particularly earth-shattering to suggest that the “fringe” label is often used to imply that an idea or thing so attributed is more unique and creative, and somehow more in tune with “the truth” – whether that be theoretically or as a subjective understanding of human experience – than the brainwashed, whitewashed mainstream. This fits with the “sanctity of the individual” perspective that is the hallmark of liberalism. People working on their own, in competition with others, in opposition to the common, will necessary create a better, more enlightened product.

Nowhere has this been better assimilated and exploited than among the youths. There, one sees the perennial cycling between the fringe and mainstream: what was fringe becomes cool… until too many people catch on, at which point it goes out of style and lays dormant until it is once again obscure enough to be appropriated by the fringe. Not to get too deterministically economic in this post, but that is a great mechanism for driving the cycles of consumption so necessary in the late capitalist era. See style.

It is a food chain. The hipsters emulate the ignored and forgotten; the popular crowd emulates the hipsters; everyone else emulates the popular crowd; and, eventually, grandma emulates everyone else. And the hipsters emulate grandma. Of course, everyone has different opinions about what is cool and what is mainstream. One person may be proud of the indie band they discovered in a movie soundtrack, while someone else will deride the band for gaining so much exposure. And then there is the constant fear that the great new band that one discovered will “sell out.”

This goes beyond pop culture. In politics, it is common to try to paint oneself as a “maverick” while portraying one’s opponent as a “Washington insider.” No one likes “the establishment.” Everyone dreams about their independent-in-shining-armor, born on the edge of society in a no-name town, emerging with integrity intact, to transform the entire political system. True, this does, in part, stem from the idea that the people currently occupying offices are visibly incompetent, dishonest, and corrupt… but we are committed to the idea that it is somehow being part of the establishment – as a personal trait – that entails mediocrity, and nothing about the structure of the establishment itself (in which case it would not matter which individuals populate it).

I should not leave out academia either, although my discussion is by no means exhaustive. Scholars scramble over each other to be part of the “fringe.” This is particularly true in the critical social sciences and humanities. In this case the “mainstream” schools of thought are associated with forces of dominance – patriarchy, the bourgeoisie, etc. The academic version of coolness is to be “marginal” and speak for (oh, no, wait, I mean “with,” I swear I totally meant to say “with”!) the oppressed. There is nothing necessarily objectionable with that sentiment in and of itself, except that it is often a superficiality which masks the general maintenance of status quo and reluctance to take real radical action. People often attempt to fashion “fringe” viewpoints without addressing the foundations of disciplinary thought, in attempt to gain a certain sort of authority or following (rather than withering in the shadows of the hot-shots). This makes me wonder whether the valorization of “marginality” really emerges from a revolutionary disposition or merely represents the transplantation of “hipsterism” into the university setting.

As for me, I don’t care where I am, so long as I have a good view.

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

European Exploitation: Phase 4

I have already described how exploitation of the so-called “Third World” has proceeded over the past few centuries according to a succession of variants (though the basic theme remains the same), and I have also explained how that exploitation has been and continues to be vital for capitalist/industrial profitability. In another post, I delineated to some extent the rigidity of the global hierarchy of wealth.

Specifically, I think it is important to emphasize that the only time during which the lower rungs make some sort of progress is when the top of the pyramid (the industrial north) experiences any kind of set-back. In a very simplistic and abstract way (which very much belies the complexity of the actual mechanisms of change), this is due to the fact that wealth is finite (based, of course, on a given level of technology) and essentially zero-sum (just like, for all you physics fans, the amount of energy in a closed system never increases or decreases, but merely changes form).

Now, on a slight tangent, I have heard some official reports from institutions like the World Bank that extreme poverty has recently been reduced around the world. Get out the champagne, right? Unfortunately, I would not put too much stock in this claim. For one thing, official statistics regarding global poverty produced by multilateral organizations like the World Bank tend to be extremely misleading and, quite frankly, useless. Not only do these organizations have agendas (as instruments of the industrial north), but statistics, in general, tend to be ineffective for understanding poverty. A true Marxist looks to structural realities and daily experiences. Take a look at any local newspaper in a Third World nation, and you will see no evidence of improvement in the conditions faced by ordinary people. (Where there are gains, these tend to concentrated at the top of the internal hierarchy, in typical capitalist inquality-increasing fashion.)

Regarding the structural realities, it is clear that the basic pecking order, the global relations of domination, has not changed. At all. And since gains in the underdeveloped world come at the expense of the industrial north, they are almost always limited and temporary.

Often, gains are temporary because the industrial north tries to regain their position in much the same way that, when two people are struggling to stay afloat in a pool, one tries to stay above water by holding the other down. This happened at the end of the 1970s. Global economic stagnation had set in by the late 1960s (caused by a crisis of overproduction and merely exacerbated by the energy crisis). As growth slowed in the industrial north, the Third World made some impressive gains. This was especially facilitated by the initial attempt of capital to find areas of investment and possibilities for cheaper production in other parts of the world.

But then the 80s, and with it the Reagan-Thatcher brand of neoliberalism, rolled in and flattened the developing world. The policies (“austerity measures,” if you will) of the industrial powers undermined all the prior investments and resulted in devastating financial crises which destroyed any economic progress made in the Third World in the previous decade.

In the intervening years we had some bubbles that did not resolve any of the underlying problems of overproduction, but made us feel pretty good about ourselves, nonetheless. Shockingly, the bubbles burst and we once again found ourselves on bumpy terrain. And once again, whose head are we going to hold under water so that we might have another gasp of air? Who are we going to screw over in an attempt to save ourselves?  It seems that the EU is busy devising new ways to drain the world of its wealth and resources.

Check It.  Sorry, Africans!

Saturday, March 17, 2012

The Recording Industry and the Monopoly on Music

I have been a long-time opponent of the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA). Around the time they began to fight against file-sharing, and well before I was able to formulate my thoughts in a very theoretical way, I was already on my crusade. Granted, my crusade has consisted mostly of being very angry, and occasionally wearing an anti-RIAA t-shirt.

Now, of course, I can pinpoint exactly where I take principled issue with the Recording Industry:

1. No one brings entirely new things into existence, and creativity depends on a free flow of ideas.
2. Music is a social, not an individual, phenomenon.
3. The Recording Industry reinforces social boundaries.
4. The Recording Industry controls the availability of music and attempts to manipulate trends and tastes

To expand on each point….

1. See post about intellectual property. But I also want to ask, why would anyone think that no one would have any incentive to create good music if not guaranteed millions of dollars in return? Have there not been troubadores, for pretty much all of human existence, willing to live meal by meal and entertaining without any expected rate of return? Do not many people choose to be musicians knowing very well that they will probably not make much money? This is the music I WANT to hear.

2. Historically, music has been created for communal purposes: special music for rituals and rites of passage; entertainment for social gatherings and dances; songs to memorialize group history and lore; songs for travel. Of course, everyone riffs off of ideas already in existence (see point number one) and widespread recycling of popular melodies has been more of the norm than the aberration. Music is very often performed with ensembles and not infrequently through collaborative improvisation. And music still plays a vital role at parties, weddings, sporting events, public venues, religious services, civic ceremonies, holiday celebrations, and is incorporated into pretty much all nonprint media forms. Now, I do not mean to be ahistorical and absolutist and suggest that the nature and function of music can never change. But the changes that have occurred have been for the sole purpose of profit. More importantly, since changes have occurred very unevenly, it is impossible to enforce copyright law consistently, and of course the punishment seems to far FAR outweigh the "crime."  Why should we consider akin to stealing a diamond something that has been so entwined with social life for all of human history?

3. It is sometimes claimed that “rock ‘n roll” finally erased racial boundaries – was the first melding of African-American and white American musical traditions. Setting aside the inaccuracy of the latter claim, I tend to get very annoyed by this utter nonsense. The boundaries were never erased. The recording industry, through its labeling and marketing techniques, has left them quite intact, if not further solidified them. The creation of charts, the organization of record stores, and the development of radio formats all depend on Recording Industry categories, which are wholly inflected with race and gender. The original term for “R&B” (the Industry’s euphemism for “black music”) was originally “race music.” At some point down the line it became not so “nice” to be that explicit, but the racial undertones remained. For example, in the 60s they felt the need to distinguish “blue-eyed soul” from plain old “soul,” in an effort, I suppose, to avoid racial mixing within a single category. I find it interesting that Hip-hop and R&B – two completely distinct genres – often appear together as Hip-Hop/R&B. The important thing is, black music is black music. On that note, I also found it interesting that Eminem (one of a scant few popular white rappers) was always played on my area rock stations, the sole form of hip-hop ever played by those formats. And then there is gender. Usually female musicians are confined to the sugary center of the industry – pop music. Even to the small extent that they have seeped into the domain of rock, they tend to be relegated to the singer role. No playing any complicated instruments for women! When female groups became popular in the rock ‘n roll era (and the new, edgy rock ‘n roll music was almost exclusively male at the beginning) they too were separated into their own marked category: the “girl group” genre. In an opposite move, the term “boy band” became popular to describe all-male groups who performed a style of music that was becoming increasingly “feminized.” Beyond race and gender, the music industry also reinforces class boundaries… but I feel this paragraph is long enough already.

4. The industry’s control over the circulation and availability of music is, I think, one of its most heinous crimes. Obviously they make it difficult for new and/or unconventional artists to “break through,” while saturating our airwaves with a couple of hand-picked photogenic performers.  Fortunately, the internet has been undermining that aspect of the Industry’s control, though only very weakly. The Industry also determines what gets played, and in what proportions, by pretty much every radio station in the country. Stations used to have a lot of independence. Not anymore. This has greatly reduced the variety of music being played. The same tired old stuff gets played ad nauseum. The Industry, taking a cue perhaps from the fashion industry, has tried many times to create new “scenes” and genres. It is constantly trying to fabricate and capitalize on “the next big thing.” (As much as individual artists try vainly to protest that they “just play rock ‘n roll man.”) They discover The Darkness and wet their pants over the “Hair Metal Revival” which certainly must follow (this, of course, being an example of utter failure). Above all else: they never EVER pass up an opportunity to exploit the passions of pre-teens…. The perennial cash cow.

The bottom line is, the Recording Industry was developed to monopolize and control. I’d rather it never existed.

Thursday, March 15, 2012

A Critical Analysis of "Art"

I think I have an arts series going on now. Expect at least one more post, about music.

"Art" is another one of those things that I consider to be merely a category rather than an independently real object (see religion). The reality is quite simple, actually: people make things and people do things. These things may be useful or not, valued or not, pleasing or not, novel or not. Probably most of these characteristics exist on a spectrum and depend, of course, on context. Hence, they are relative.

The application of the term "art" to certain crafts and activities has been entwined with other socially meaningful divisions, and a more detailed genealogy of the term than I can provide might illuminate the history of its meaning and function more fully. Loosely, though, it helped to demaracate the domains of the sacred and profane, and then to differentiate between the productions of the educated uppercrust and those of the ignorant masses (labeled, in contrast, "folklore").

Through its contemporary usage, "art" has been universalized and tied to the concept of human subjectivity (as an "individual expression"). This is no surprise, given the universalizing tendencies of "modernity" (as discourse and project), as well as the central role played by the idea of the subject in modern social formations.

There have been plenty Marxist analyses of art. For example, noting the way in which different aesthetics contribute to the rigidity of the class hierarchy. Also the way in which art patronage provides a safe outlet for capital which may not be profitably invested (the Medicis, e.g.), and thereby maintaining some systemic stability. I do think these points are extremely useful and worth keeping in mind. However, I am more interested in the way in which art functions both in the discourses and social/institutional structures constituting "modernity," as a means of objectifying individual subjectivity and notions of "culture."

Once objectified, subjectivity/culture may enter the capitalist market as a commodity (and art forms of various sorts do seem to be the primary way in which individual and collective subjectivities are commodified). The transformation of individual subjectivity into a form of "property" provides the rhetorical material with which the legal basis for monopolies (copyright law) is constructed.

Even when subjectivity objectified does not enter into any market relations, it may still have market value.

But most importantly, it is venerated as a sacred, powerful artifact. Because subjectivity is conceived as the mysterious key to human knowledge of the world and our own condition, art allows us the possibility of understanding our own history, diversity, and motivations. Paradoxically, it fulfills our almost technocratic urge to rationalize every aspect of human life, in an effort to control and improve.

As a result of both this preoccupation and the dynamics of capitalist production, "style" becomes eminently important and an object of ceaseless contemplation (generally leading one to consider how certain individuals developed new styles, or how one style emerged out of another). Usually, narratives of style take an evolutionary form and buttress the ideology of progress (even when, contradictorily, some room for arbitrariness is allowed). And of course, the succession of styles feeds into the capitalist need for constant novelty and osbolescence.

All of this to say: art is another thing that emerged as an integrated whole, though in manifold and complex ways, with the other processes and institutions associated with modernity. It is a piece of modernity, or rather, multiple pieces (as it is not a single thing): a byproduct of the concept of subjectivity; an expression of particular subjectivities; a tool of governmental/reformist impulses; a form of economic value; and a means of reinforcing particular ideas/discourses, to name a few.

No sense in trying to define it. More fun in seeing how it works in practice.