Showing posts with label terrorism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label terrorism. Show all posts

Sunday, April 21, 2013

Most Terrorism is Not Islamic

The first person I talked to about the Boston Marathon Bombing - as soon as it came on the news - insisted it had to be jihadist.

Yes, everyone assumes that all or most terrorist attacks are carried out by Muslims.

When it turned out that the perpetrators were, in fact, Muslim, everyone immediately concluded (once again, in the absence of any evidence) that their religion must have something to do with their actions.  That could turn out to be true. But it is also possible that they were motivated by some Chechen liberation cause that had nothing to do with Islam (national liberation movements/sympathizers have committed more terrorist acts in the US than jihadists). And it is also possible that personal trauma (the best friend of one of the brothers was brutally murdered) or some other factor that has nothing to do with either their religion or ethnicity is really to blame. We just don't know. But the fact remains that all of the media discussions about the brothers' potential links to Al Qaeda and other Islamist groups just serves to reinforce the idea that all terrorists are Muslims and all Muslims are terrorists.

So I gave up on the media and started looking at the FBI's published lists of terrorist activity. What I found, overall, backs up the claim that about 6% of terrorist incidents in the U.S. are Islamic. I saw that there has actually been more Jewish terrorism than Islamic.  And just to give you a sense of how rare Islamic terrorism really is: there were more incidents involving the Earth Liberation Front in 2001 than incidents involving Muslims from 1980-2005.

Now, it seems as though the incidents that have involved Muslims have received proportionately more attention than any other religious or political group (and that's an understatement). That just shows how skewed people's perceptions can be as a result of dominant ideologies promoted by the media. However, the consequences are severe: Muslims (or anyone who looks Arab or Muslim to the undiscerning eyes of Americans) are discriminated against; they get detained for hours whenever they travel because they are deemed automatically suspect.

The reality as demonstrated by the FBI data makes it absolutely clear that Muslims are being treated unfairly.


Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Muslims and Racism

Although racism of all varieties obviously still abounds, it appears that Islamophobia is currently the one form that is socially acceptable to express openly. Once again, as I have said numerous times, I do not think the "who is more oppressed?" game is very productive. Thus, my concern in this post is more the way in which racism is explicitly (as opposed to covertly) part of public rhetoric.

The other day I was talking to an older woman, and the subject of the state of Michigan came up. She said, "Oh, they have a lot of problems" (I expected her to say "with the economy" or " with unemployment" or "with foreclosures) "... they have all those Muslims." She was referring to the city of Dearborn, Michigan - a suburb of Detroit - which has the largest Arabic population outside of the Middle East. I don't think this woman realized that many of these people of Arabic descent are Christian, not Muslim. (Lebanese Christians, who came to work in Ford's factory, provided the original pull of Middle Easterners to the area.) I politely explained that Dearborn is a very nice community - no major "problems" of which I am aware, expecially compared to those facing Detroit.

I don't think this woman would have been very comfortable making a similar comment about African Americans (though Detroit is largely African American, and there has been racial tensions along black-white lines for decades). Yet, she did not hesitate in the slightest about making a "Muslim" comment.

Somehow, the fact that some Muslims have been involved with terrorism makes it "valid," in many people's opinion, to speak critically about Islam and to treat Muslims/Arabs/Middle Easterners differently. Nevermind the fact that "Islamic terrorism" (a problematic term in itself) only represents a tiny percentage of all terrorism in the U.S., or the more obvious fact that the vast, vast majoriy of Muslims do not have anything to do with terrorism.

This reasoning is not new: for example, when we were at war with Japan, overt racism and discrimination against Japanese Americans was suddenly trendy. Though Islamophobia definitely is an interesting case, in that it involves the conflation of race, nationality, and religion. Anyone can claim that they are not racist, but just have problems with the (supposed) tenants of the religion. This demonstrates the way in which "cultural reasoning" is often used as a more "progressive" sounding stand-in for racial reasoning (I expect to write a more detailed post about this topic sometime soon). Put plain and simply, rhetoric about "cultural difference" is often just thinly veiled racism.

In the case of Arabs/Muslims/Middle Easterners, "cultural difference" is a totally inappropriate framework in which to understand terrorism. Arabs, Muslims, and Middle Easterns have all been subject in different ways to colonial rule, neocolonial manipulation, capitalist exploitation, and racism of the "Orientalist" variety. This is the framework in which to understand terrorism. To avoid repeating myself, here are some links to previous posts on the subject:  MENA Dictatorships and Colonialism; The Death of Osama Bin Laden; Religion and Colonialism in MENA.

(And why is it that the "collateral damage" caused by U.S. military interventions in the MENA region is not considered "terrorism"?)

This just goes to show that, despite all the "progressive" trends that have occured throughout the past couple of centuries, we have not gotten past the point of socially acceptible racism.

Sunday, July 24, 2011

Scandinavian Islamophobia

It goes without saying that the terrorist attack in Norway was horrific.  Somehow the fact that all of those children were involved makes it that much more difficult to stomach.

It also serves as a reminder of something that many people in the United States remain oblivious to:  there is a lot of immigration to Europe from the Middle East/North Africa, and there are a lot of Europeans who are hostile to these people.  There is a lot of nationalism and a lot of Islamophobia.

Back when there was all that controversy surrounding the Danish cartoons depicting the prophet Mohammed, many people in the U.S. could not comprehend the reaction of some Muslims.  But thanks to racism, we had a ready-made framework with which to make sense of these events:  namely that Muslims (or Arabs more generally) are irrational and prone to violence.

The reaction was incomprehensible to people in the U.S. because they did not realize the depth of the tensions that existed within Europe.  They did not realize how many Muslims had to live in fear and degradation.  These events in Norway, however, lend some credibility to those fears.  There are people in Europe who hate Muslims so much that they are willing to do something so extreme and erratic as kill dozens of innocent children.

Now, that is not to say, of course, that all Europeans are that Islamophobic (that goes without saying), nor that Europe is the only place in which one can find Islamophobia.  The U.S. gives Europe a run for its money in that regard.

But I do think it is important to remember how wide and how deep Islamophobia extends.  It is absolutely necessary to understanding events taking place in the Middle East and around the world, as well as some of the actions taken by some people of Islamic faith.

When we hear about people proclaiming Holy War against the U.S. or the industrial north, or whatever given entity, we must consider:  who proclaimed war first?

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

The Death of Osama Bin Laden

It is clear what significance the death of Osama Bin Laden has for the vast majority of the American public, liberal or conservative. The kind of reaction that is occurring is not the least bit surprising.

But what does the death of Osama Bin Laden really mean? The answer to this question boils down to whether one views the problem of terrorism in terms of individuals or systems. If the former, then one is likely to see acts of terrorism (most notoriously 9/11) as the expression of individual defects: psychological disturbance, moral depravity, an essence of pure evil, personal feelings of anger and resentment. Possibly religion plays a role, but only in so far as religion is characterized as a set of beliefs that may populate and shape an individual's consciousness. The antedote to a "bad" religion, then, is the spread of either a better religion, or of Western humanistic rational thought (or both).

Religion, culture, ethnicity, and images of "evil" human beings, in fact, have all been used to great success as a smokescreen to obscure the real nature of violence, terrorism, and warfare. If the general populous feels (or are made to feel - often through the creation of dubious internal and external "threats") a strong attachment to a particular religion, ethnicity, nation-state, or if they desire to "fight bad guys," then these rationales work as a great motivating force to support endeavours which would be totally unpalatable otherwise.

However, from an anthropological standpoint the following can be argued: violence is not just "human nature"; blind passions and hatreds may stir masses of people to action, but they do not ever cause coordinated, strategic acts of violence. Violence is systemic. In terms of the lived experience of the general population, religion, ethnicity, ideology, etc. do fuel war, but only as part of an overarching strategy that has nothing to do with any of those things.

Thus, I would argue that terrorism must be understood in terms of systems, and not individuals. Our entire global political-legal-economic complex is sustained by, legitimizes, and naturalizes violence. The political/legal system that constitutes the nation-state, as well as the "community of nations," is fundamentally premised on the concept of "legitimate violence." The state is, in the last instance, an apparatus of coercion and a means of "legitimate" violence. Other state functions are not indigenous to the state apparatus and extend beyond the state itself. Even our legal system and concepts of "justice" work to uphold the legitimacy of state violence.

Moreover, relationships that enable large-scale accumulation of wealth, and in particular, those pertaining to modern capitalism, employ violence in a very systematic way to maintain structures of exploitation and unequal exchange. The development of capitalism and industrial society would not have been possible without the violence of colonial conquest and slavery. Capitalist aims continue to be pursued through the support of coups and brutal regimes, political assinations, and full-scale invasions of other countries. This is in addition to the violence of extreme poverty and malnutrition, abuse suffered in the workplace, etc. etc. Add to this the forms of violence that sustain the social division of labor: the violence of patriarchy, racism, and xenophobia.

In essence, violence is a characteristic of a type of relationship: more specifically, a relationship of inequality. It is the very fabric of our current social structure. However, violence is not the only characteristic of relationships of inequality, and it is by no means a necessity of human existence. It is a historically determined phenomenon.

Therefore, when terrorists employ violence to challenge neo-colonial domination, they are simply utilizing what is immediately at their disposal - the methods (and, often, the knowledge, tools, and resources) of the system in which they are enveloped - as a means of resistance. Perhaps this demonstrates the difficulty of acting (even thinking) completely outside of the structures one is challenging.

So what does this say about the death of Osama Bin Laden? A man was killed. The system was not. In fact, as Bin Laden's death entailed further state-sponsored violence (including, it now appears, the inhumane interrogation techniques at Guantanamo Bay), it stands as a victory not for the families of 9/11 victims or first responders or ordinary Americans, but as a victory for systemic violence. The system will persist, and so will violence of all kind.