It is a basic assumption of Marxism in general that revolution is the engine that drives structural change. Marx predicted that a global proletarian revolution would facilitate the post-capitalist phase of social evolution (his version of socialism). Neo-Marxists look toward fledgling revolutionary movements as the harbingers of salvation from capitalism.
Recently I was discussing with someone my belief that the world is on the verge of large-scale transformation. My conversation partner expressed doubt about the ability of current populist/revolutionary movements (MENA revolutions, Occupy Wall Street, etc.) to effect substantial change, while I insisted that they could very well intensify and merge into a single force.
But then I began to think about the assumptions I was making concerning revolutions. The last two major global transformations (1400s and 1700s) were organized in a significant way by the merchant class. This occurred because the merchant class lay outside of the relations of the dominant mode of production (focused on agriculture and hierarchical transfers of agricultural surpluses). Thus, the merchants were able to forge new relationships with the oppressed (peasant) class and the ruling class, as well as create new global webs of trade to support these relationships. In other words, the existence of a peripheral class with the ability to accumulate wealth is significantly responsible for the structural transformations that eventually resulted in the capitalist system.
It is important to note that there were peasant revolutions, and none of them were able to accomplish large-scale structural transformations. The revolutions that gave birth to capitalism, as Marx noted, were "bourgeois" revolutions - or, struggles between the bourgeoisie and the soon-to-be-overthrown ruling class. The bourgeoisie became the new ruling class.
So, if that is the case, why should the revolutions of the oppressed be any more successful this time around? There is just no historical precedent.
For Marx, a revolution of the oppressed was necessary because he believed that what followed capitalism had to be the apex of social evolution, which for him involved the elimination of all forms of exploitation and oppression. The only way this could occur would be if the oppressed themselves took a stand and dissolved all relations of domination. (If anyone else were to take charge of the revolution, they would simply become the new oppressors, much as the bourgeoisie did.)
But what if that which comes after capitalism is not a utopia free of exploitation? What if things get worse?
At the very least, I can say this: right now there does not appear to be a group of people akin to the merchant class who lie outside the bounds of capitalism, and who could initiate a political economic transformation of global scale. In this sense, I believe that Marx was right. It seems that there is no one else to take the revolutionary reins but the world's oppressed.
On the other hand, I do not believe, as Marx did, that this is a given. The oppressed might not actually try to transform the system, or at the very least they may be unsuccessful.
Furthermore, it seems possible that the ruling class could make an attempt at global transformation themselves, once they have finally exhausted (as they pretty much already have) the possibilities of the current system.
The conversation partner mentioned above mused that we have reached a terminal point, the end of the line. No possibility for any more transformative change. This is another possible scenario. I remain skeptical about the degree of stasis that can ever be achieved, however, as power is too disunified, contradictory, incompetent, and ultimately prone to undermining itself, to maintain any degree of stability. Already, one can see an increasing amount of disorder within the world system, including the gradual dissolution of its major geopolitical arrangements.
The bottom line is that, in this case, it is difficult to predict the future based on historical patterns, and there is no reason to assume that a proletarian revolution will or has to occur. I do, however, still feel confident in forecasting a long period of economic stagnation and political chaos. And as I view the world in which we live as a dystopia, from my point of view there is nowhere to go but up. Or... nowhere.
Showing posts with label historical materialism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label historical materialism. Show all posts
Sunday, November 13, 2011
Revolution of the Oppressed
Labels:
historical materialism,
revolution
Wednesday, September 7, 2011
Historical Materialist Explanation of Social Institutions
One of Marx's most enduring legacies is his approach to historical analysis, commonly referred to as "historical materialism." It rests, in part, on the principle that at any given time the possibilities of existence are limited and shaped by what already exists. History is not a random succession of eras, ideas, and cultures. Neither is it teleological: in other words, its coherence is not in any relation to any end result (although Marx's view of history is somewhat teleological). Rather, the "progress" of history is driven by the collective and contradictory attempts of human beings to adapt to a pre-formed world - a world that is not of their own creation - and shape it to their own needs. Obviously, the least amount of work, the smallest amount of change to accomplish this task, the better.
In this way, historical materialism stands in contrast to functionalist brands of social theory, which explain social realities (often focusing on "the institutions" - family, economy, religion, schools, government, etc.) in terms of a function that may be intended but just as likely is below the realm of consciousness. Functionalist reasoning goes something like this: "X [social institution] exists because it functions to ______ [create social bonds, effectively allocate scarce resources, manage behavior, socialize members into particular roles, diffuse conflict, etc.]" Thus, social institutions come into being in order to serve a specific purpose, and are created and maintained in a rather mystical way (independent of the activities of individual people).
On the other hand, defining an institution as a highly coherent network of people, ideas, material artifacts, processes, and relationships, a historical materialist would emphasize how the same collection of human and material resources can be used by different people for different ends. Furthermore, the existence of any particular social institution is not a given, it is a historical peculiarity. If a certain nexus of social artifacts and relationships happens, regardless of the original reason for its formation, to be useful to someone with a certain degree of social dominance, it will persist, perhaps with some alterations to adapt it to new purposes. Or it might be dismantled entirely, with segments of the network incorporated into other new or existing networks.
*******
I raise these issues as a sort of theoretical introduction to a series of posts I intend to write about education. Seeing as to how the fall is approaching and school started this week, I thought it would be apt. My goal is to provide an alternative to the generalized functionalist framework which characterizes public discussion of education and outline how one might view the role of educational institutions in a capitalist society.
In this way, historical materialism stands in contrast to functionalist brands of social theory, which explain social realities (often focusing on "the institutions" - family, economy, religion, schools, government, etc.) in terms of a function that may be intended but just as likely is below the realm of consciousness. Functionalist reasoning goes something like this: "X [social institution] exists because it functions to ______ [create social bonds, effectively allocate scarce resources, manage behavior, socialize members into particular roles, diffuse conflict, etc.]" Thus, social institutions come into being in order to serve a specific purpose, and are created and maintained in a rather mystical way (independent of the activities of individual people).
On the other hand, defining an institution as a highly coherent network of people, ideas, material artifacts, processes, and relationships, a historical materialist would emphasize how the same collection of human and material resources can be used by different people for different ends. Furthermore, the existence of any particular social institution is not a given, it is a historical peculiarity. If a certain nexus of social artifacts and relationships happens, regardless of the original reason for its formation, to be useful to someone with a certain degree of social dominance, it will persist, perhaps with some alterations to adapt it to new purposes. Or it might be dismantled entirely, with segments of the network incorporated into other new or existing networks.
*******
I raise these issues as a sort of theoretical introduction to a series of posts I intend to write about education. Seeing as to how the fall is approaching and school started this week, I thought it would be apt. My goal is to provide an alternative to the generalized functionalist framework which characterizes public discussion of education and outline how one might view the role of educational institutions in a capitalist society.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)