In many interpretations of disparate current events, analyses often boil down to the same basic principle: at some point in the recent past, national boundaries were created (whether purposefully or not) that do not align with regional “tribal” or ethnic divisions. One should of course always be troubled when a single explanation can unilaterally describe so many diverse situations, but particularly so when it is based on the assumption of “natural” and enduring social boundaries.
To some extent I have already discussed issues of human identity, the malleability of social groupings, and the discursive use of terms like “tribalism” in my post on (fittingly) tribalism. Some of those arguments apply here as well. In short: human racial/ethnic/tribal groupings are historically contingent, ever-changing, and lack clear boundaries in practice; however, the image of these categories as eternal and “natural” social facts is strategically used to imply the inevitability of violence and poverty in certain regions of the world.
These same arguments apply to the case of national boundary creation and warring ethnic groups. Whether it’s Sudan/South Sudan, Iraq, Rwanda/Burundi or anywhere else for that matter, the following assumptions are incorrect: 1) The rival ethnic groups have always existed; and 2) Violence is inevitable because group loyalties are too strong.
Generally, violence, though fundamentally a matter of social structure, is also tied to distribution of resources, which plays out differently in different regions - though, in the modern world, almost always following the same capitalist principles. Thus, struggles in various parts of the world are based more on differential access to resources and wealth than on enduring group loyalties. Although it is true that social identities are continually evolving and reflect current as well as historical context, at the same time, the idea of timeless and natural group identities often exacerbates such conflict, and determines the particular shape that it might take in a given locale. This identity-based escalation of violence may be incidental or intentional (if identities are fostered by colonial powers for the purpose of engendering conflict). Either way, however, group identity, while playing a role, still cannot be held as the root cause of violence.
There is one additional implication of the “group identity” theory of violence. It obscures any awareness or understanding of actual material reality (especially with regard to distribution of resources) that is vitally important to really addressing these issues and, ultimately, transforming society.
Showing posts with label ethnic conflict. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethnic conflict. Show all posts
Wednesday, May 16, 2012
Saturday, July 16, 2011
Colonial Legacies in East Africa
East Africa has been getting some attention in the news the past week. First, there was the establishment of South Sudanese independence. Then there has also been the severe regional drought. If there is a pattern to my blog posts about global current events, it is the my constant irritation by the way in which colonialism is bracketed in the reporting of these issues. The East African stories are no exception! In fact, two seemingly unrelated stories like drought and ethnic/religious conflict are actually connected by colonialism - the tie that binds everything.
Drought
I have already mentioned, briefly, that the global poverty that exists today is a result of colonialism (when Europeans forcefully rearranged the relations of production in such a way that the colonized oriented all productivity toward the satisfaction of European demand, rather than to meet local needs.... a situation which persists today). Many people in the U.S. (and I would venture to guess in western Europe as well?) believe that poverty is caused primarily by environmental factors, and a situation like the current East African drought only serves to strengthen those convictions.
Yet, when Europeans reorganized production in the colonies, not only did they prevent the colonized from directing production toward their own local needs, it also hindered their ability to adapt to climactic fluctuations and respond to environmental hardships. East Africa, at the time of colonization, was a primarily pastoral region, whose economy focused on the very mobile practice of cattle herding. This has been very common among people who live in dry zones, as pastoralism is particularly well suited to such a climate. The communities in East Africa were nomadic and, in the case of drought, were easily able to move to new locales. They could adapt!
Colonization and the subsequent erection of nation-states with very static boundaries has been ruinous to the lives of many East Africans. For instance, in the current drought, those who try to move to better areas (and generally these are people who are more advantaged than the rest of the population) find that they have to cross national borders and, in the world of nation-states, are now considered "refugees": the only people in the world whose human rights cannot be protected.
Drought is only a problem because people no longer have the ability to move at will. Drought is not just an environmental issue. It is a social and political issue.
Sudan
In some of my posts on MENA and colonalism, I wrote about how religious, ethnic, and sectarian differences were created and/or exaggerated by the colonial powers in order to disunite the population and diffuse the strength of forces of resistance. Such is the case in Egypt and Sudan as well. In this region, England's tactic was to create religious segregation, and hence tension, between Christians and Muslims to prevent them from acting as a single force. In Sudan, a distinct barrier was created between the predominantly non-Muslim (Christian and other religions) south and the Muslim north in order to isolate the two different groups (as well as allow Christians more exclusive access to the indigenous religious groups for ease of conversion).
That worked out nicely, didn't it?
Drought
I have already mentioned, briefly, that the global poverty that exists today is a result of colonialism (when Europeans forcefully rearranged the relations of production in such a way that the colonized oriented all productivity toward the satisfaction of European demand, rather than to meet local needs.... a situation which persists today). Many people in the U.S. (and I would venture to guess in western Europe as well?) believe that poverty is caused primarily by environmental factors, and a situation like the current East African drought only serves to strengthen those convictions.
Yet, when Europeans reorganized production in the colonies, not only did they prevent the colonized from directing production toward their own local needs, it also hindered their ability to adapt to climactic fluctuations and respond to environmental hardships. East Africa, at the time of colonization, was a primarily pastoral region, whose economy focused on the very mobile practice of cattle herding. This has been very common among people who live in dry zones, as pastoralism is particularly well suited to such a climate. The communities in East Africa were nomadic and, in the case of drought, were easily able to move to new locales. They could adapt!
Colonization and the subsequent erection of nation-states with very static boundaries has been ruinous to the lives of many East Africans. For instance, in the current drought, those who try to move to better areas (and generally these are people who are more advantaged than the rest of the population) find that they have to cross national borders and, in the world of nation-states, are now considered "refugees": the only people in the world whose human rights cannot be protected.
Drought is only a problem because people no longer have the ability to move at will. Drought is not just an environmental issue. It is a social and political issue.
Sudan
In some of my posts on MENA and colonalism, I wrote about how religious, ethnic, and sectarian differences were created and/or exaggerated by the colonial powers in order to disunite the population and diffuse the strength of forces of resistance. Such is the case in Egypt and Sudan as well. In this region, England's tactic was to create religious segregation, and hence tension, between Christians and Muslims to prevent them from acting as a single force. In Sudan, a distinct barrier was created between the predominantly non-Muslim (Christian and other religions) south and the Muslim north in order to isolate the two different groups (as well as allow Christians more exclusive access to the indigenous religious groups for ease of conversion).
That worked out nicely, didn't it?
Labels:
Africa,
colonialism,
drought,
ethnic conflict,
poverty,
religion
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)